4 ms·
I'm extremely pro-union, but this decision makes sense to me. If you're a developer going on strike, you don't get to turn off the production database before y
by crazygringo 3y ago
I'm extremely pro-union, but this decision makes sense to me.
If you're a developer going on strike, you don't get to turn off the production database before you leave the building.
Now obviously there's always going to be a gray area between sabotage/destruction and not showing up for regular work duties. Continuing the developer analogy, if you know the production database is going to run out of disk space in 4 days, that's not your problem.
But halting work mid-shift with concrete that will dry out and could damage the trucks is extremely irresponsible and totally unnecessary in the context of labor negotiation. I can't see any legitimate reason why it's necessary to leave your job mid-shift in a labor dispute if that will result in damage. The union should either have called for the strike to begin before the shift or allowed workers to finish their shift.
There's no reason for property damage to be part of labor negotiations.
- CharlesW 3y ago> …if you know the production database is going to run out of disk space in 4 days, that's not your problem. […] I can't see any legitimate reason why it's necessary to leave your job mid-shift in a labor dispute if that will result in damage. So, your rule is that it's okay for blue collar workers to strike as long as they don't leave during their shift, and for white-collar workers to shift if it doesn't impact the business the same day? > There's no reason for property damage to be part of labor negotiations. Striking hurts the company by definition. Whether the result is that concrete dries out, or fish go bad, or production servers are killed, or television production is halted doesn't matter.
- gruez 3y ago>Striking hurts the company by definition. Whether the result is that concrete dries out, or fish go bad, or production servers are killed, or television production is halted doesn't matter. Right, but there's an obvious difference between hurting the company through lost production, and hurting the company through lost production and deliberately engineering scenarios where work stoppages would cost maximum damage.
- CameronNemo 3y agoNo, the difference is not "obvious". In some industries and workplaces, there will always be damages due to work stoppages. Otherwise the laborer wouldn't command a competitive salary.
- gruez 3y ago>In some industries and workplaces, there will always be damages due to work stoppages. Please read my previous comment again. My claim isn't that there won't be damages due to work stoppages, just that there's a difference between damages caused as a side effect of work stoppages (eg. lost production), and work stoppages deliberately timed/engineered to cause max damage. A sibling comment[1] listed out other examples. Surely you see the difference between the scenarios listed and simply not showing up to work one day? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36178614 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36178614
- supernova87a 3y agoThe union waited until the concrete trucks were poured/loaded/on their way to call the strike action, in order to exact intentional and maximal damage to the company. That doesn't seem to me as normal business losses and striking to increase one's bargaining position. That borders on extortion. I think the difference is "obvious".
- CameronNemo 3y agoWell, enjoy your reality.
- supernova87a 3y agoSure. I guess my reality is the one that's compatible with our laws.
- CameronNemo 3y agoYour laws, not ours.
- supernova87a 3y agoSo intentional property damage is just a reasonable part of the right to strike? An aircraft mechanic decides to strike by walking out of the tow vehicle that he's driving, while it's moving, causing the airliner that vehicle is towing to ram into the hangar. That's legit? A gas station fuel delivery truck driver decides to strike after starting the pumping of a load of fuel, intentionally (and foreseeably) causing the tank to overflow because he's no longer on the job to stop it. Just a cost of business and reasonable strike behavior? How about the auto body shop workers decide to strike right after removing all the wheels from your car on the lift, intentionally starting the job first? What principle are you advocating for exactly?
- CharlesW 3y ago> So intentional property damage is just a reasonable part of the right to strike? I'm not sure where you get "intentional" from — as I read it, the workers assumed business as usual until the strike was called, and in the end no damage was done. But in the hypothetical where it was intentional and did cause property damage, is $1M in property damage worse than $1M in digital damage (like a production database failing) or lost revenue?
- supernova87a 3y agoMaybe read the case and form an opinion based on what the facts are rather than assuming what the facts are based on the opinion you want to hold? > "...Tensions came to a head on the morning of August 11. According to the allegations in Glacier’s complaint, a Union agent signaled for a work stoppage when the Union knew that Glacier was in the midst of mixing substantial amounts of concrete, loading batches into ready-mix trucks, and making deliveries. Although Glacier quickly instructed drivers to finish deliveries in progress, the Union directed them to ignore Glacier’s orders. At least 16 drivers who had already set out for deliveries returned with fully loaded trucks. Seven parked their trucks, notified a Glacier representative, and either asked for instructions or took actions to protect their trucks. But at least nine drivers abandoned their trucks without a word to anyone. Glacier faced an emergency. The company could not leave the mixed concrete in the trucks because the concrete’s inevitable hardening would cause significant damage to the vehicles. At the same time, the company could not dump the concrete out of the trucks at random because concrete contains environmentally sensitive chemicals. To top it all off, Glacier had limited time to solve this conundrum. A mad scramble ensued. Glacier needed to determine which trucks had concrete in them, how close the concrete in each truck was to hardening, and where to dump that concrete in an environmentally safe manner. Over the course of five hours, nonstriking employees built special bunkers and managed to offload the concrete. When all was said and done, Glacier’s emergency maneuvers prevented damage to its trucks. But the concrete that it had already mixed that day hardened in the bunkers and became useless." (page 5 of the court's opinion)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- timmaxw 3y agoThe specific rule applied by the Supreme Court was: > The National Labor Relations Board [NLRB] has long taken the position—which the parties accept—that the NLRA [National Labor Relations Act] does not shield strikers who fail to take “reasonable precautions” to protect their employer’s property from foreseeable, aggravated, and imminent danger due to the sudden cessation of work. The rule is nuanced, and courts have considered the case of perishable goods specifically. See my other comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36178491 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36178491
- CameronNemo 3y agoif you know the production database is going to run out of disk space in 4 days, that's not your problem Uh... My interpretation of this decision is that is 100% your problem.
- gruez 3y ago1. the decision is that the lawsuit can proceed, not that it's the workers' "problem" 2. regardless unless you take a slippery slope interpretation to the ruling, it's doubtful that any and all losses related to work stoppages (even ones that are days/weeks out) are the workers' "problem"
- veave 3y agoA better analogy would be... there's this migration you have to run that consists on shutting down the service, doing something, then turning it on. So you shut down the service and immediately leave. Which I agree is simply destructive.
- specialist 3y agoGlacier has no agency? They proceeded to fill the trucks despite the threat of a strike. As noted elsethread, Glacier could keeping refilling the trucks, postponing the strike indefinitely. Further, per the NLRB, the law permits this kind of strike. Here's a summary of each side's arguments. https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/21-1449 https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/21-1449
- a_cardboard_box 3y agoThe case wasn't about whether property damage was allowed as part of labour negotiations. It was about whether the courts or the NLRB should handle the case. So this sets the precedent that a company can skip the NLRB and take their striking employees straight to court over hypothetical property damage (since in this case the trucks weren't damaged).
- mola 3y agoBut the very act of striking is hurting the business, that's the whole point. It's the only leverage workers have. Ofcourse actual vandalism is different, and there are laws against it. But allowing for suing damages caused by strikes is just a way to crush workers rights and return most of the power imbalance to favour the owners.
- gruez 3y agoIsn't this a slippery slope argument? The claim by the company isn't that they lost money due to the strike and therefore the union has to pay, it's due to the workers deliberately going on strike at a specific time to cause damage and therefore the union has to pay.
- irq-1 3y agoDid management know the date or time? Management is responsible for scheduling the cement trucks. Separate from this issue, a lawsuit is a huge burden to place on workers. For striking to remain any kind of negotiation we can't have workers going unpaid and then buried in legal expenses. Everyone will just quit instead of striking, and workers will have lost what little power they have now.
- gruez 3y ago> Did management know the date or time? Management is responsible for scheduling the cement trucks. According to a sibling comment[1], no. >Separate from this issue, a lawsuit is a huge burden to place on workers. For striking to remain any kind of negotiation we can't have workers going unpaid and then buried in legal expenses. Giving the workers a pass on illegal behavior just because they're on a strike doesn't sound too good either. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36179122 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36179122
- aaomidi 3y agoDo employees get to pick the time and date they get fired? No? Then the company can fuck right off. The Supreme Court needs to not forget what the worker union landscape looked before NLRB. The only reason NLRB and federal union rules are relevant is because the workers have for now accepted that. That can change.