3 ms·
It certainly helps that we're moving on from "It's irrelevant" to "Actually this is important and it's bad if it's broken". When would you say that happened for
by tialaramex 3y ago
It certainly helps that we're moving on from "It's irrelevant" to "Actually this is important and it's bad if it's broken". When would you say that happened for the Web PKI? Not last century when the Web PKI comes into existence for sure. Maybe if you squint you could argue for the Baseline Requirements in 2011 as a starting point ? Or maybe the Ten Blessed Methods which was only a few years ago?
The browsers do have leverage over the TLDs, and over the DNS resolvers, in the form of how they choose to treat names and name services. For example check the "trusted resolver" policies at Mozilla and Chrome, which IIRC got big US ISPs to swear off nonsense like injecting bogus results into DNS in exchange for having the browser work with their DNS servers.
- agwa 3y agoBrowsers have leverage over CAs because CAs have to ask browsers to be included in the first place, and because distrusting a CA only temporarily breaks websites until they can switch to a new certificate. What kind of leverage do you think a browser could practically exert over a TLD?
- tialaramex 3y agoAs just one example, they can change presentation. Remember the CAs were able to sell an otherwise useless change in presentation for a considerably increased price, you will still occasionally run into people who thought that was crucial to their business.