4 ms·
> Game design is limited by the technology of its time. Lara Croft's face was poorly defined, and her features were exaggerated partly because it wasn't possibl
by cubefox 3y ago
> Game design is limited by the technology of its time. Lara Croft's face was poorly defined, and her features were exaggerated partly because it wasn't possible to render an attractive quasi-realistic character before the first generation of 3D hardware. The renders shown in promos and cover art were done in much higher quality, and the Lara in those hardly resembled the in-game Lara either.
Well, the article explicitly shows an early sketch where she looked even more comic-like than in the final renders. The character was never intended to look realistic, that wasn't just a technical limitation of the hardware the game run on. In fact even for Tomb Raider 6 the renders didn't look realistic:
https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/laracroft/images/e/e4/Tr6-model-011.jpg https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/laracroft/images/e/e4/Tr6-...
> You're saying that Mario and Snake didn't also change from their initial 2D sprites to their later 3D models? Mario's nose and signature cap were hardly distinguishable in the early games, and just weren't important compared to the gameplay.
There were some early changes, but Mario looks basically exactly like he did on the cover of Super Mario Bros 3 some 25 years ago:
https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/8csAAOSwH9JeGgLT/s-l1600.jpg https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/8csAAOSwH9JeGgLT/s-l1600.jpg
Even Tomb Raider 1 - 6 did not have that much continuity.
> Her defining features are being an upper-class explorer and overall badass, which is part of every TR game.
That could also be someone else. Lara Croft now looks like a completely different woman. And very generic too, nothing like the distinctive face (and with the braids, and the exaggerated proportions) she had before. The continuity of the first six games is simply lost, it's like replacing Homer Simpson with some different, slimmer, more average looking character, while still calling him Homer Simpson.
Maybe they wanted the series to have more realistic graphics, which wouldn't fit her classic stylized design. But I'm sure they could have come up with a design that looked at least similar to the old Lara. Even cosplayers do a decent job:
https://prd-rteditorial.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/22162820/Laura-Croft-Classic-Costume-Tomb-Raider.jpg https://prd-rteditorial.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/wp-conten...
https://abload.de/img/66872776_280264737309kmfka.jpg https://abload.de/img/66872776_280264737309kmfka.jpg
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BingLee 3y ago>Even cosplayers do a decent job Ha ha. And what would they know about character design! The new design has proven sticky amongst a proportion of the cosplay community at the very least, and that surely is a useful bellwether.
- imiric 3y ago> Even Tomb Raider 1 - 6 did not have that much continuity. If you're talking strictly about the physical appearance, sure they did. TR 1-5 are basically the same game, running on the same engine, and Lara looks practically the same. These were all released within a span of 5 years, so it's no wonder only incremental changes were done. TR 6 was the first attempt to redesign the character, but then again, the game setting and direction was entirely different. After that flopped, the series went on hiatus until the very well received 2006 reboot with Legend, which was developed by Crystal Dynamics instead of Core Design, so the changes aren't surprising. > The continuity of the first six games is simply lost, it's like replacing Homer Simpson with some different, slimmer, more average looking character, while still calling him Homer Simpson. I see your point, but video game characters are much more fluid than cartoon characters. For one, the content is released every few years, and each release gives designers the chance to tweak the appearance. Moreover, the technology changes rapidly, which makes some features possible that weren't before, and designers tend to experiment with that. The free-flowing hair braid wasn't possible before the first TR game, and neither was making a character "attractive", so they leaned into those features in the early design. But it doesn't mean that these are the defining features of the character. Ultimately this boils down to the creative vision of the creators, and how strictly they want to stick to a single design throughout the series. Considering the TR IP changed hands several times, it's likely that designers were given the freedom to experiment. BTW, those cosplayers are enacting the early version of Lara, but notice that those sunglasses aren't fashionable anymore, and realistically, that outfit is highly impractical for the exploring that Lara is supposed to do. So if the artistic vision for the project changes for whatever reason, so will the character appearance. As long as they keep the fundamental traits of the character, their physical appearance shouldn't matter. At least to me it doesn't, but you're free to disagree, of course. :)
- cubefox 3y agoOkay, my main complaint is that she looks boring and generic now: https://cdn1.epicgames.com/offer/4b5461ca8d1c488787b5200b420de066/egs-shadowofthetombraiderdefinitiveedition-eidosmontralcrystaldynamicsnixxessoftware-s4-1200x1600-7ee40d6fa744_1200x1600-950cdb624cc75d04fe3c8c0b62ce98de https://cdn1.epicgames.com/offer/4b5461ca8d1c488787b5200b420... https://www.play3.de/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Shadow-of-the-Tomb-Raider-5-705x397.jpg https://www.play3.de/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Shadow-of-th... That's just a standard NPC attractive woman face. If she at least had a braid, this alone would make her much more recognizable. If you showed a random gamer the character from the most recent TR game and asked them from which game it is, many would have no idea. Some TLOU NPC? The old Lara would be much more readable from the head alone. https://www.allgamestaff.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/tr6_r_20.jpg https://www.allgamestaff.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/tr6_r... A more realistic design could also work: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/40/03/3e/40033e34f90a2344d46367e1387ac261.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/40/03/3e/40033e34f90a2344d463...