3 ms·
I'd burn that entire jungle down if it brought us industry, development and prosperity in exchange. Why is it that only developed countries got to exploit their
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
I'd burn that entire jungle down if it brought us industry, development and prosperity in exchange. Why is it that only developed countries got to exploit their natural resources?
- was_a_dev 3y agoTo be fair, it wasn't even their natural resources
- piva00 3y agoIt happened 100-200 years ago in developed countries, we know better now that it isn't something to be replicated. Or are you also willing to have child labour working 12-16 hours/day to achieve industrialisation? Burning that entire jungle down to achieve short-term economical development will doom future generations, you achieve development and prosperity for 20 years while leaving a bleak future for the next 50-200 years. For what? Making some cars? Mining some ore? It's the second moronic take I came across from you in this comment chain, you're parroting Bolsonaro's demagogy, it feels like you haven't thought yourself about the consequences of "burn that entire jungle down". I don't believe you are that stupid so please, give it a deeper thought than this knee-jerk angry reactionary take. It sounds extremely moronic.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> For what? Making some cars? Mining some ore? Defense industry? Semiconductor fabs? Pretty much anything? You name it dude. I'm just sick of my country being the world's barn. Producing soy and shit. I wish Brazil had balls to do what China did. > you're parroting Bolsonaro's demagogy Please. I don't care at all about Bolsonaro. He's irrelevant. I had this opinion before he even took office. It's not that I "haven't thought of the consequences", it's that I really don't give a shit. I literally couldn't care less that there's going to be a price -- I'd pay it gladly, if it brought prosperity and power to my nation.
- piva00 3y ago> It's not that I "haven't thought of the consequences", it's that I really don't give a shit. I literally couldn't care less that there's going to be a price -- I'd pay it gladly, if it brought prosperity and power to my nation. That's the whole issue: you aren't the one who is going to pay for it. I'm originally from the same nation as you, that's exactly why I'm calling you moronic. Semiconductor fabs don't depend on the Amazon being burnt down. Defence industry does not depend on the Amazon being burnt down. These depend on political stability, well-educate population, State investment in R&D for the future, economical policies that foster national industries through the whole chain, fiscal policies (and stability of those) that don't overburden small R&D companies. Custo-Brasil encompasses all of that: political instability, fiscal policies that are burdensome to abide to, a poorly educated population, bureaucratic inefficiencies, so on and so forth. That's what need to change in Brazil, not fucking burning the Amazon down, that won't bring any prosperity as the elites would be unchanged, they would still pillage and loot you and the rest of the population, as it's been done since the 1500s.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoNever said those things depended on burning down the amazon. I said I'd totally sacrifice it if doing so paid off. You're calling me a moron because you took my post literally. Truth is I don't even disagree with the rest of your points. The sentiment I tried to convey was "the amazon doesn't matter, we have bigger problems to worry about". That's the most polite way I found to express what I feel when I see people worrying about a jungle in a country that's unable to provide basic sanitation to all its citizens. Especially those living in said jungle, and there are many. At least it's a relatively noble cause. I'm a lot less polite when it comes to intellectual property.
- nec4b 3y ago>> For what? Making some cars? Mining some ore? This one of the most champagne socialist positions I had a privilege to witness. Thank you for this.
- Rexxar 3y agoYou got it reversed, developed countries have stopped to use their forest when they industrialized and start to use coal/oil instead of wood and when increase in food production make the use of less productive land unnecessary. Thinking you can be richer by destroying Amazonia is pure delusion. For example, the forest is bigger in France now that is was 1000 years ago : http://geoconfluences.ens-lyon.fr/geoconfluences/images/articles/img-dodane/15-000-ans-dhistoire-forestiere-3000px.png/image_view_fullscreen http://geoconfluences.ens-lyon.fr/geoconfluences/images/arti... Destroying forest is a short term low-productivity cash grab. It will not make any country rich.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> Thinking you can be richer by destroying Amazonia is pure delusion. What? Literally any economical activity you can think of would be a better use for that massive amount of land. If you told me I could have a billion dollar fab built in my country but the only place I could build it was in the middle of the amazon, it wouldn't take me even one second to decide. Did you know there's oil reserves in the amazon? People in the government keep making noises about that. Every once in a while I see news about some environmental drama concerning the extraction of petroleum in that region. I wish they'd just do it already.
- Rexxar 3y agoI don't see the point of your examples - A billion dollar fab will be 0.00001% of the forest. - Oil can be extracted without destroying forest
- matheusmoreira 3y agoBillion dollar fabs and oil rigs will create a ton of jobs and attract a lot of people to their surroundings. That means housing, local services to serve and sustain that population, local infrastructure paid for by increased tax revenue. The increased economic activity will attract more capital and start a self-sustaining cycle that will develop and improve vast areas. Everyone will want to be there to get a piece of that prosperity. I know because I literally live in a city where this happened. Steel industry. When my parents came here, it pretty much was a jungle. Now they call it the Steel Valley.
- 11235813213455 3y ago> prosperity are you a business man? https://thestorytellers.com/the-businessman-and-the-fisherman https://thestorytellers.com/the-businessman-and-the-fisherma... enjoy your life without pollution, drought etc, instead of money
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYeah, enjoy your life under the de facto rule of greater nations who could sanction you to oblivion and take everything you have by force any second they wanted because you have a joke military that's only good for painting roads in peace time. Worked great for the original inhabitants of Brazil when the portuguese came in 1500, now they depend on communists for property rights.
- 11235813213455 3y agoyou've the same kind of talk and hate than some African with colonialism Personally I don't give a damn about nations, I care about the planet as a whole, I live in France but nowhere like the average, more like a third-world person (I don't even have a fridge, not hot water, nor heating or AC, just to give you an idea), so your talk doesn't make sense to me
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYou may not care but I do. I would very much enjoy seeing Brazil become a powerful country. If I hate anything it's the weakness of our governors who are perfectly happy in their positions as globalist puppets. They are always seeking the next great power so they can align themselves with them. Once upon a time that was the United States. Now it looks like it's China. Wish they had the balls to aspire to be the next great power instead.