3 ms·
Another example where they said elected officials can handle it, no matter how disruptive. I see consistency. A court that was acting like a super legislature
by yieldcrv 3y ago
Another example where they said elected officials can handle it, no matter how disruptive.
I see consistency.
A court that was acting like a super legislature along partisan lines could easily have taken much further advantage than that, and …. didn’t? They didn't say “its banned, bye”. they said “elected officials should be handling this” no matter how disruptive that is, which is only disruptive because elected officials did not address the issue because they were hoping to be elected again
yes, lying to get appointed is a common strategy in the US. I dont think that has bearing on the merit of the ruling itself. I see consistency and congruence, and I dont see absurd wild interpretations that people suggest is occurring
- nawgz 3y agoHahaha what, they literally overrode 2 past court’s rulings after saying they wouldn’t. The judicial branch overrode a decision ruled on TWICE, decisively, bipartisanly, with no new legislature involved. That’s only consistent with interpreting them as partisan hacks who don’t respect their institution.
- yieldcrv 3y agoThe blind spot with this common and oft-repeated perspective is that this was near the median amount of time it takes for the Supreme Court to overrule itself. Meaning this wasn’t unique or rare or an outlier. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31962613 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31962613 the rationale presented in the case was a reversion to the mean, where the court doesn't function as a surrogate for the legislature. grasping at the procedural aspects of appointment because the judicial review was sound but disruptive suggests that these aren't strong arguments about the judges.