3 ms·
> I don't see how this is materially different from Axios' analysis? Because Axios is saying: > This raises major questions about the future viability of dire
by crazygringo 3y ago
> I don't see how this is materially different from Axios' analysis?
Because Axios is saying:
> This raises major questions about the future viability of direct listings, which some companies believe are a more efficient alternative to IPOs. / In practice, SCOTUS told investors in direct listings that they should not rely upon information contained within stock registration statements. Given that giant warning sign, it's unclear why anyone would buy into a direct listing, and thus why any company would attempt one.
But this is ignoring the fact that you can still sue under section 10 (regular securities fraud) as opposed to section 11 (IPO fraud), which the Money Stuff article explains.
People will be no less willing to purchase shares in a direct listing than they are to purchase shares in any public company any day of the week.
Axios is claiming this will be a death knell for direct listings (their editorial opinion), while the Money Stuff article comes to no such conclusion. That's the material difference.
- lolinder 3y agoMoney Stuff doesn't say it'll be the end of direct listings, but they do say that section 10 is much harder to sue under and therefore removing section 11 limits the company's liability a lot. It doesn't seem that far fetched to go from there to "so investors will avoid the risk".
- crazygringo 3y agoBut it's still the same risk of normal everyday trading of shares. So it does seem pretty far-fetched to me. If you followed that logic, the entire stock market would grind to a halt.
- lolinder 3y agoIt's not quite the same, because with other stocks you have months or years of past performance to go on.
- psidebot 3y agoBut it also seems likely that companies will decide to take advantage of the reduced liability (especially now it's confirmed and not just theorized) and investors will just price in the risk difference.
- jquery 3y agoIn such a situation, honest companies will get hurt and dishonest companies will get helped. How is this good for the ecosystem? Reminds me of crypto ICOs.