4 ms·
> The whole building isn't economic or productive. They could probably make more money tearing it down and replacing it with a Starbucks. It likely has econom
by ceejayoz 3y ago
> The whole building isn't economic or productive. They could probably make more money tearing it down and replacing it with a Starbucks.
It likely has economic impact vastly larger than any Starbucks via tourism.
- barelyauser 3y agoAnd what does "economic impact" means? A bunch of people burning jet fuel to get there and spend some hours looking at it? Why not working towards helping other people?
- ceejayoz 3y agoBuying from the cafes nearby. Patronizing the hotels. Going to see a show after. All the things one does in the neighborhood around a tourist attraction. A week-long golf tournament in my town brings in 200k+ people and local government touts a $190M economic impact number for that. I'm sure it's fudged to be as high as possible, but pretending Notre Dame doesn't have an economic benefit to Paris would be odd.
- barelyauser 3y agoMoney means nothing. Human time is what matters. Consider that back at their place of origin things did not get done. Economic impact means nothing. If I gave you $100 to watch me do nothing, what value this transaction created? There is virtually nothing to show for at the end but we created $100 of economic impact...
- ceejayoz 3y ago> If I gave you $100 to watch me do nothing, what value this transaction created? That seems entirely up to you.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoI have always been disgusted by this sort of low, mediocre, pseudo-moral argument. "Why build these grand churches? You could feed people with that money!" "Why put all this effort into beautiful buildings? You could build more low-income housing for the same cash!" It sickens me. We can do both. Man does not live by bread alone. Utilitarian mediocrity is satisfied with a full stomach and keeping warm.
- seszett 3y agoNot all tourists in Paris comme from far away, probably a majority of tourists came by train or car. I never take a plane to visit Paris.
- jfengel 3y agoAdmission was free to the cathedral itself, though you needed to pay to visit the roof. Of course it was a draw to Paris in general. It's hard to measure its impact, since the cathedral fire coincides with COVID, but Paris tourism has nearly reached pre-pandemic levels and remains the most-visited city in the world. I don't honestly believe it would be a net economic benefit to put a Starbucks there. But more to the point, the whole thing is there just because people like to look at it. That's all the "productivity" it needs.