3 ms·
I think this really pops the bubble of the fantasy of the ultra-productive scrappy individual running circles around stodgy old corporations, because the little
by jeffbee 3y ago
I think this really pops the bubble of the fantasy of the ultra-productive scrappy individual running circles around stodgy old corporations, because the little hacker is exploiting Codex or Copilot. It seems in reality the outcome is the opposite: AI is amplifying the advantages of large incumbent software companies. They have the data and the resources to train and deploy this stuff. They've been using it in practice for years and they aren't planning to share it with you.
- sebzim4500 3y agoYeah but at least one of those incumbents seem allergic to releasing actual products, so I wouldn't count the scrappy individuals out just yet.
- jeffbee 3y agoGoogle has more—much, much more—to gain from being a highly productive software developer than they stand to gain from selling software development tools to outside users.
- dwaltrip 3y agoMy intuition is that the new crop of AI tools is still higher leverage for individuals than for large organizations. And given how software development historically has scaled sub-linearly with org size, I expect we will see interesting developments as these tools continue to improve. Advancements should magnify the leverage differential. However, if tools like those discussed in the article can change the equation of how software development scales with org size, then maybe that changes things. I do agree that large orgs will gain a lot here as well. But I’m not sold that they will gain more than skilled individuals, proportionally.
- oceanplexian 3y ago> AI is amplifying the advantages of large incumbent software companies. In large software companies (I've worked for a few) the bureaucracy always seems to scale exponentially more than the 'productivity'. So you end up waiting on a build system that takes 5 hours, you have to use some old library because it's pinned in a monorepo, reviews from other engineers that take days, a Staff Engineer wants to give his opinion so the project gets delayed another week, another manager feels threatened by your idea so he shuts you down, etc. AI won't solve any of this, it will just allow increasingly more convoluted bureaucracy to be created. Compare that to a scrappy developer or startup, they can run literally run circles around big tech. The only thing is they don't have is as much money or resources, but they have a ton of advantages getting things to market, where AI can be used to increase productivity without all the red tape.