5 ms·
The question is why your belief is so widespread. The battery pack in a Telsa S or X model was literally 7000 flashlight batteries in a metal box. The newer sta
by jeffbee 3y ago
The question is why your belief is so widespread. The battery pack in a Telsa S or X model was literally 7000 flashlight batteries in a metal box. The newer standard-range pack from the 3 and Y models has thousands of larger cylindrical cells that won't literally fit in standard flashlight but which are nevertheless off-the-shelf Panasonic catalog batteries.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> The newer standard-range pack from the 3 and Y Just the Y. The standard range pack for the 3 is prismatic LFP. And I think the standard range Y may be haded that way. There was also a recent rumor that the newest 3LR is now LFP, but I don't know if that's been confirmed.
- acyou 3y agoThis is a little bit of an over-simplification. These particular 21700 and 4680 Panasonic cells are not off-the-shelf or catalog. As far as I know, they were designed specifically with the EV application and Tesla pack in mind. And to my knowledge, the Tesla Panasonic cell variants only exist in Teslas. We could not take some other 21700s and make a roughly equivalent pack without a good deal of effort. The thermal characteristics, impedance, length, width, diameter, would be different. There may not even be any cells available with equivalent form factor and performance characteristics. We haven't seen Tesla or anyone else taking "commodity" 21700 cells and mixing and matching them and throwing them into a pack, it's not possible to do that. Usually, we pick one or two cell manufacturers. It's telling that even Tesla, with their massive buying power, doesn't purchase from LG, Sony or Samsung, only Panasonic in the West for NCA and CATL in China for LFP. Why exactly do we think that is? It's not quite at the level of people saying computer chips are commodities, and you can just plug your device into one interchangeably. But these cells are not easy and simple. We tend to just think something's easy because we don't have good experience with it. For lithium ion, under the hood, there's enough complexity and risk that the details become very important, very quickly.