3 ms·
Having reviewed articles can be a legitimate signal. My brother started working in high school on research that was ultimately published in a peer reviewed phys
by rayiner 3y ago
Having reviewed articles can be a legitimate signal. My brother started working in high school on research that was ultimately published in a peer reviewed physics journal. (Maybe if he’d gotten that article out before graduation he wouldn’t have gotten dinged at MIT.) But he only had that opportunity because he went to an elite public school in Virginia that had a program to get students internships with the dozens of defense industry research labs in the area. Not exactly something that’s available to folks in Iowa, where my wife went to high school.
And getting published in a non-science journal probably provides a much weaker signal. For cultural reasons, lots of families wouldn’t even think it would be worthwhile to have their kid published in say a social science journal. (My dad, who has a sociology degree, told me in no uncertain terms that I wasn’t allowed to major in the subject.)
Really it’s another reason that college admissions should just be based on test scores and grades. If the kids are poor—give them an $1,000 scholarship to take an PowerScore class. (That’s just a fraction of what even poor school districts spend on each student annually.) Everything else is so wildly subjective or unevenly available to kids around the country.