3 ms·
Could you point to specific deficiencies of HN?
by dredmorbius 3y ago
Could you point to specific deficiencies of HN?
- bug21512 3y agoIt doesn't support proper pagination for comments, and has been promised as an upcoming feature for years.
- pb7 3y agoCan you explain what you mean by proper pagination? It breaks up comments into multiple pages so it must be something else.
- twic 3y agoNo pagination, as mentioned. No way to keep up with new comments on a post (Reddit doesn't have this either). No notifications on reply, so it's difficult to get answers to clarifying questions (/threads helps but isn't it). Ever-increasing indentation makes deep threads hard to read. Generally hard to read and hard to click on mobile. None fatal, but also none particularly tough to fix!
- Sebb767 3y ago> No notifications on reply I'm pretty sure this is intentional in order to avoid shallow discussions and not grab too much attention. I actually like this, but I agree with you that it can make it harder to get answers sometimes and you do miss some replies, on especially older comments.
- swores 3y ago> No pagination, as mentioned. Not sure what you mean by this, the lists of posts are very obviously paginated, as (admittedly a bit awkwardly) are larger comments threads. Maybe you mean auto-scrolling pagination? > No notifications on reply, so it's difficult to get answers to clarifying questions (/threads helps but isn't it). While not a HN feature, there is a simple solution - http://www.hnreplies.com/ http://www.hnreplies.com/
- dredmorbius 3y agoAs with others, I'm not sure what you mean by pagination. The lack of response notification is a feature, though yes, it can be annoying, and I find the degree to which comments or questions go unresponded is ... disappointing. That said, notifications abuse by modern Web / App systems is rampant. I'd like some sort of middle-ground, perhaps a responses / notifications link which would consolidate these. "Threads" is the closest there is to that, though it includes all a person's comments whether (newly) responded to or not. Mobile experience is pretty poor, agreed, though it's sufficient for reading logged-out (my preferred mode). Composing text on mobile devices is a category error. Deep threads (and greyed text with downvotes) is a very intentional site design. pg's discussed that in the past, see: "What I've Learned from Hacker News" (2009) <https://www.paulgraham.com/hackernews.html https://www.paulgraham.com/hackernews.html> Discussed at the time: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=495053 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=495053> And four years ago: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19210923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19210923> Some of the site styling can be overridden with CSS. I apply the following on desktop: Dred's HN CSS Madhackery: https://pastebin.com/gLXiqKyd https://pastebin.com/gLXiqKyd There's also a dark mode I've created: Dred's HN CSS Madhackery -- Dark Mode: https://pastebin.com/6PF3dCXH https://pastebin.com/6PF3dCXH
- Karunamon 3y ago- Lacks basic responsiveness (would not be difficult to make links/buttons larger on phones while impacting nothing for desktop; as it stands they are very hard to hit on mobile) - Long threads become unreadable due to shifting right with no end as replies come in, occasionally becoming comical - Supports just enough markdown (asterisk italics, indented code blocks) to lead people to think they can use all of it (want bold, or in-line code? You lose.) - Code blocks are unreadable on mobile since they cannot be scrolled - Despite being an obvious design choice, breaking accessibility by reducing the contrast of unpopular comments is a deficiency.