3 ms·
So Facebook uses the exact same trick. They could have just omitted the P3P header completely, but no they must and shall have 3rd party cookies so they respond
by tripzilch 15y ago
So Facebook uses the exact same trick. They could have just omitted the P3P header completely, but no they must and shall have 3rd party cookies so they respond with an invalid P3P header, just like Google.
The fact that the invalid P3P header contains the string "We don't support P3P and here's why" is a red herring:
The only reason why they would place a statement regarding their non-support in the very header that they claim not to support, is to circumvent IE-users' privacy policy. It's very disingenuous.
If you don't support it, leave out the header, if you want to make a statement that says "We don't support the P3P header", don't put it in a place that really says
"We disagree with the P3P header and believe in circumventing it.
Read why here: http://xyz"
If FB or Google's headers had said that, at least it wouldn't have been as disingenious. Saying you don't support P3P--oops! and by saying that we broke it! whoops!
It's a bit like placing a sticker "WE DONT SUPPORT READING THE LEFT HALF OF A SIGNPOST" over the left half of a "NO ENTRY" sign. Childish.
It would be interesting if we could see that list of other 500 companies. Because "there's 498 others that do it too" has a very different implication depending on what sort of company Google and Facebook find themselves in by acting in such a childish manner.
- freehunter 15y agoIf it's broken to begin with, it's not really "breaking the users security settings". Specifically if it can be broken just by saying "break it", then it's broken from the start.
- tripzilch 15y agoIn that sense NO ENTRY signs are also broken. And so is the robots.txt protocol.
- stanleydrew 15y agoBut "No Entry" signs and robots.txt are broken for the same reason. We all know that, so how is it a counterargument?
- freehunter 15y agoNo one trusts their security to a sign or a robots.txt. Get a security guard and an encrypted directory, and get a better way to manage your cookies.
- bad_user 15y agoNo, they couldn't omit the P3P header.
- tripzilch 15y agoWhy, did someone tattoo it onto their servers?
- zerostar07 15y agoEven from your description, P3P does not work; IE is equally dishonest imho for claiming that P3P provides any kind of privacy.
- tripzilch 15y agoIt's a crappy protocol, I agree. I don't see how that's relevant though.