5 ms·
> manipulate the conditions so that the intervention is unlikely to help > [The study] would use all the best practices You've go some major contradiction her
by eviks 3y ago
> manipulate the conditions so that the intervention is unlikely to help
> [The study] would use all the best practices
You've go some major contradiction here, since when is such manipulation "the best practice"?
- Vecr 3y agoWell, is giving 50% of people placebo parachutes and having them jump out of a plane at altitude considered best practices?
- satisfice 3y ago"Best practices" is always bullshit, man. It's a marketing term, not an engineering or a science term. Any practice is bad or good based on the context and purpose for which it is applied. That's the spirit in which I used the term. In plain English: you can correctly apply certain practices that are famously powerful and acceptable, while subtly undermining them in a way people might not notice, or would happily pretend not to notice if the study fits with their political position on the matter.
- eviks 3y agoThen your supposedly serious point resolves to a tautology "people can bs if they do bs". Duh! This conveys nothing re. any scientific technique or using that in arguments against some intervention
- satisfice 3y agoI am explaining the point of the paper. If you don’t think a parody based on that point is useful, maybe take it up with the take it up with the authors, Duh!