4 ms·
Perhaps, instead, we can see this as a good thing and plan a graceful way back to a more sustainable population over the course of a century. Just yesterday yet
by throwaway29291 3y ago
Perhaps, instead, we can see this as a good thing and plan a graceful way back to a more sustainable population over the course of a century. Just yesterday yet another in a long line of reports talked about how humanity has not just bent but likely broken many of the Earth's ecological boundaries that humans and non-humans alike depend upon. We've known this for decades -- mountains upon mountains of studies in ecology, climate science, and many more fields. We've largely chosen to ignore it all and keep forging ahead with resource consumption and waste production.
Part of the challenge to conventional logic of what I wrote above is that the economy, in standard neoclassical economic thought, is separate from the ecosystem. The two interact, but are entirely distinct. Sometimes human society is another distinct third bubble. Instead, ecologists have long known that the ecosystem of today (and likely for the decades of concern here) contains human society which contains the human economy. So, we're better off planning a graceful descent -- one that will have less competition for resources and less harm to the global ecosystem.
- whaleofatw2022 3y agoUnfortunately, the likely reality is that the ones who can afford to continue reproducing will also continue to consume an unfair amount of resources.
- judge2020 3y agoConsumption of resources in general is the problem, and that only happens at a scale where population growth remains stable or increases. It's not the difference between even 90% of newborns eventually doing something like modding their car to roll coal instead of using bike transportation.
- Telemakhos 3y agoI think the answer is the opposite. Consumption of resources is proportional to standard of living: it takes resources to make the most modern lifestyle available. The demographic collapse, however, is evident in highly industrialized societies like Korea, while backwards regions with a low standard of living still have high birthrates. Subsaharan Africa, for example, consumes less than Korea per capita but has a higher birthrate. It seems more likely that higher rates of resource consumption are correlated with lower birthrates.
- amrocha 3y ago>Consumption of resources is proportional to standard of living It's not and you know this. It's at best correlated. The resources have to be used effectively, and right now they're definitely not. My quality of life does not go up because using up more resources instead of living sustainably.
- tzekid 3y agoHigher living standards are directly correlated with higher energy and resource consumption. Unless you're living in a far distant village or in the middle of the woods producing everything you use, you're using an immense amount of resources in your everyday life. Recycling, not buying the latest tech and curbing your diet don't make any significant dent into the amount of resources you're indirectly consuming by simply living and being active in a well-off, first-word or even "second-world" society.
- amrocha 3y agoNah. I moved from Canada to Japan last year, and my quality of life has increased at the same time that my consumption has decreased. Correlation is not causation.
- throwaway3838g 3y agoI agree with this sentiment but wonder… as long as there are humans, is an ever increasing resource consumption and waste production inevitable? Isn’t this unquenchable desire for more intrinsic to humans? Yes, this means we will probably blow the planet it up, but is there any other way?
- DirectorKrennic 3y agoWith a sufficiently low and stable population, of, say, 50 million, renewable resources, such as water, wood, nitrogen, and fertilizer could be reused indefinitely. But non renewable resources, like oil, natural gas, and metals will eventually become permanently extinct, like oil and natural gas, or will have to be recycled in perpetuity, like metals. This is what awaits us sooner or later anyway.
- mlsu 3y agoI've seen this take before, especially around climate and the environment. It's correct that having 20,000 humans on Earth would be more (actually indefinitely) sustainable. These "degrowth" strategies mean tremendous suffering. People have to die to make degrowth possible. Those who stick around have to suffer of curable medical complications. They have to live hard lives without the comforts of modern life. Why do we need to descend? It's not strictly necessary: the "environment" has enough fissionable material for nearly limitless electrical power. The "environment" has enough raw material to increase the amount of computation on our planet by many orders of magnitude. And that's if we stay here on Earth -- if you want to think on "indefinitely" timescales, Earth's constraints may not apply. It's profoundly cynical. I don't actually understand it. All of this technology, this art, this incredible organization that the modern world provides, and think "we need to turn back, tail between our legs, and give up."
- throwapine 3y agoCan you provide sources for those claims?
- UncleOxidant 3y ago> These "degrowth" strategies mean tremendous suffering. People have to die to make degrowth possible. But nobody's saying they have to die early. A fertility rate under replacement will lead to degrowth. Yes, it's going to be difficult during the degrowth phase (less young people to support the aged), but eventually the population will stabilize at a lower level and that will be better from both a sustainability and resources standpoint.
- mlsu 3y agoBut not a human standpoint! Billions of old people, dying alone. I do not want to live in that world. Let alone encourage it!
- throwapine 3y agoThe alternative is continue killing trillions of animals a year and polluting the air, water and soil until our biosphere is no longer suitable for many species including humans. At that point we can forget about exploring the stars or whatever.
- ChatGTP 3y agoIMO "AI" and Robotics will completely destroy any chance of this happening. Imagine armies of robots working 24/7 strip mining everything, logging everything, way faster and way smarter than people ever could. This is what we're making, this is what capitalism will absolutely love. There is no sign of any regulation here from governments, they will want it even more, "GDP! GDP! GDP!". I was really hopefully we'd actually get to a nice place, it would be rough with climate change, but there would be less people and we'd look back on the 21st century with disdain and try live more simple lives, slower lives, it looks like we're going to try 100x everything instead. If we get to the stage where people do live much longer, this will be the next issue, people never dying and the Earth basically filling up. It will be the next drama we can obsess over :) I might be wrong, maybe we'll start mining asteroids or maybe the economy will collapse quick enough the singularity will be cancelled due to lack of demand (funny I know). It's very hard to say, but I hope I'm wrong and you're right!
- faeriechangling 3y agoYour vision is unrealistic. Society would eventually distill down to two bots trading increasingly large amounts of money between eachother until the end of time after first jettisoning themselves into space.
- ChatGTP 3y agoYou think this is impossible??
- pyuser583 3y ago“Ecosystem contains society contains economy” I hear this a lot, but it seems more like a slogan. Ecologists have disproven dialectical materialism? Or Hegelian idealism? I doubt that very much.
- HaroldBolt78 3y agoThat's not going to happen, though. Population growth will continue whether you're having children or not. Western economies are Ponzi schemes and the ones needing your votes know it. You may not have any kids, but there are millions of Africans, Indians, and Chinese ready and willing to flood your country, and there are politicians only too eager to see them pouring across undefended borders. Some of these countries are seeing 9+ births per woman; there will be no shortage of new people to replace your non-existent grandchildren. The solution would require some degree of ethnonationalism, else how do you argue against this policy? From a "we are all the same" viewpoint, it is unremarkable if Canada is 100% ethnically Indian and Chinese in 200 years; if Britain and Australia are African colonies; if America is... American. The very thought of racial discrimination in immigration, however, is totally unpalatable and unconscionable to most Westerners, and thus there is still no solution. Your descendants' positions will be filled. There is no depopulation fantasy in the West's future. There can only be replacement.
- incomingpain 3y ago>Perhaps, instead, we can see this as a good thing and plan a graceful way back to a more sustainable population over the course of a century. I love the optimism but it's difficult to see this as a positive. Lets consider china. For decades they had a 1 child policy and according to their own numbers even worse problem killing their daughters. "sex selective abortions" then most believe. China has a huge proportion of incel men who probably at no fault of their own cannot find a wife. They blame themselves and they become violent. Stemming from loneliness, and feeling of failure. Nothing is new here. History has tons of these examples and 100% of the time the host country of the incels can't keep them at home. So they are sent abroad. Who is planning to take millions of incel men from china? Yikes... so it 100% of the time has led into an invasion. Imagine having 100 million men who want to be violent and you can invade a neighbour? That's what you do. Will it be different this time for the first time? I doubt it.
- andrewjl 3y agoDo you have a concrete proposal for such a "graceful descent"?