4 ms·
All interventions that don’t require a patient being in a coma first requires patient compliance. Diet and lifestyle are nearly impossible to address from the
by lazide 3y ago
All interventions that don’t require a patient being in a coma first requires patient compliance.
Diet and lifestyle are nearly impossible to address from the perspective of the Dr, as they require the patient to want to and be willing to change foundational elements of their life. Unless the patient comes to you requesting that, good luck.
Many will get actively angry if you mention even obvious and severe issues like obesity, to the point of slandering Dr’s or avoiding going in for serious issues later.
Taking a pill, patients will often be able to do that (but definitely not always!).
Getting a surgery, similar.
Is it any wonder that Dr’s use the tools that people will let them use, instead of the ones people won’t?
- DoreenMichele 3y agoI have no idea why both of these comments assume that I am talking about treating people with only diet and lifestyle. Other than possibly prejudice and people know more about me than they are willing to admit. I'm talking about doctors having a tradition of being some of the wisest and most knowledgeable people in a community and going to someone's home allowing them to know things about their lifestyle by seeing it with their own eyes instead of taking a history and hoping the patient didn't lie or leave out something important. And we've lost a lot of medical wisdom that will not be available should some version of the tricorder ever empower doctors to take MRIs, x-rays and similar diagnostics to the patient's home in their little black bag. Those traditions are gone, possibly forever, as an unintended side effect of placing tech on a pedestal above human wisdom. I'm talking about diagnosing things effectively, not denying people drugs and surgeries. And I don't intend to reply further because from where I sit, it looks to me like HN is going out of its way to intentionally misunderstand me here lately.
- lazide 3y agoI don’t know why you think I was saying only diet and lifestyle, because I definitely wasn’t? You seem to be imagining that this scenario where the Dr. Goes to your home and gives you something useful was ever a mainstream phenomenon, which as far as I’m aware is just not true. So maybe the issue is not HN?
- WalterBright 3y agoMy dad was sent to a nutritionist to deal with his spare tire. She gave him a meal plan, and told him to come back in a couple months for a followup. When he did, she was shocked that he'd actually followed the meal plan, and his spare tire deflated the expected amount. He kept it deflated for the rest of his life, though he said it was a constant struggle.
- tcmart14 3y agoGlad it worked for your dad and I can definitely see it working for others. Part of the difficulty with being told that I need to make life style changes is how open ended it can be. It can make it hard to plan or know what to do or stick with it. I can definitely see it makes the on ramp to life style changes so much easier if you're given a plan and have to think little about it. This helped me. My doctor recommended a diet and gave me sites with meal plans so while I was trying to navigate my way through it, I had resources to get me going the first few weeks.
- lazide 3y agoAwesome stories! A key element in them (IMO) is in both of them the end result was recognized to be in the hands of the person doing it (not the Dr.), and they put the work in to accomplish it because they believed it was important for them. And that work was tractable. For many people, the hard part is getting to the point they (mentally) are able to do that, which is the psychiatric and environmental elements IMO. If someone has been convinced that they can't actually solve the problem, or that it is dangerous to solve the problem, they will avoid trying, or sabotage themselves when it looks like they could potentially succeed. If someone is in an environment where it is impossible to get proper nutrition, or get time/space to try things or do the planning required, or where they aren't allowed to make the decisions necessary for a better outcome, then they'll also be frustrated and unable to make the change. Luckily, both are addressable except in very rare edge cases, but it is rarely comfortable or easy to do.
- andbberger 3y agotreating obesity like a lifestyle condition and not a bonafide disease and dismissing patients with vague recommendations to eat less and exercise more is ignoring the overwhelming body of evidence supporting that behavioral interventions don't work and that the body has strong homeostatic mechanisms which fight efforts to move the weight set point. i can only hope that you're not a doctor
- lazide 3y agoSo what do you propose? Because what you wrote sounds a lot like ‘it’s unsolvable’, which is clearly not true either. Gastric restriction is an extreme solution, and rarely that effective long term. Pharmacological is often fraught with serious side effects and also has poor long term efficacy. In my experience it’s usually psychiatric and environmental, which is why it’s hard to tackle, and nearly impossible without patient willingness to change - and that’s always hard. Even if willing to change, being able to change is often very difficult too as it’s rarely one factor.