3 ms·
> Statistics are meaningless to the individual. This is just blatantly untrue. > means little compared to an individual who already drives safely without it
by ceejayoz 3y ago
> Statistics are meaningless to the individual.
This is just blatantly untrue.
> means little compared to an individual who already drives safely without it
Until emergency breaking stops a bad driver from T-boning you in an intersection as they run a red light.
“I’ll just drive safely” was the argument against seatbelts, airbags, and antilock brakes. Motorcycle helmets, too.
- hedora 3y agoCan current emergency braking systems realistically stop a t-bone accident? Sure, if it was equivalent in capability to a class 5 self driving car, it would see the light was red, and notice the partially occluded other car, then stop in time. But, with just a front facing radar? I don’t see how it would be able to do much. It would only have a few feet to stop.
- ceejayoz 3y agoEven a reduction in speed helps - 10 mph can make a significant difference in lethality - and sub in being rear-ended if you prefer. The point is even a perfect driver may benefit from safety devices in the hands of other drivers they encounter.
- hallway_monitor 3y agoThis is a good point, thank you. I don't think anyone here would argue against this feature if it was 100% accurate. However, mandating something that has many reports of erroneous activation seems like overreach.
- ceejayoz 3y agoDefective airbags blew shrapnel in folks’ faces, too. Anecdotes are of limited value here; I’m sure you can find the occasional person who has been trapped in a car by a seat belt and burned to death. Policy needs data, not unfalsifiable claims of being a perfect driver hobbled by computer interference. The article notes: > A metanalysis in 2015 found a 38 percent decrease in collisions for vehicles that utilized such a system, for instance.
- Tanoc 3y agoForward emergency braking systems don't detect such situations. You'd be hit regardless. They only have a 170 degree field of view at the best of times in their current implementations. Somebody two hundred feet away closing at sixty miles an hour will hit you in the side regardless of forward emergency braking simply because it's not designed to look for something moving that quickly that far away at that extreme of an angle. That said there's also a balance in safety systems between personal responsibility and systems responsibility. Relying too much on systems responsibility actually causes more harm because the person becomes more careless or is entirely at the whim of the system responsible for their safety. We put railings on stairs in public places but don't require everyone to put on a safety harness and latch it onto the guide to climb stairs for example. There's an expectation that system safety has hit a reasonable limit and the safety harness is too costly in time, money, and attention to implement.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe car doing the T-boning can see forward, and even slowing down by 10 mph can halve the lethality of the resulting crash. Full success isn’t necessary for benefits. Or sub in a high speed rear-ending scenario.
- janalsncm 3y agoThis reminds me of the fact that many foreign subway systems have outer doors (so you can’t just walk onto the tracks) and inner doors. Most people won’t just walk onto the tracks in America but the outer doors address inattentive people, tired people, and people who want to do the wrong thing. In a lot of places the outer gate is only chest high which isn’t insurmountable but is enough of a barrier to avert 99% of the bad cases. I think the analogy to automatic braking holds.
- ChatGTP 3y agoI’ve never had a bad accident in a car, but the closest I have ever come was in my friends new VW with lane assist on a dark country rode on a bend when the lane markers vanished due to wear. I started to get lazy and distracted as the car was mostly driving, my friend was talking at me and the assist disengaged, next minute we were going pretty fast towards a barrier. We recovered but it was close. I’d just prefer to drive honestly.
- dabluecaboose 3y ago>> Statistics are meaningless to the individual. >This is just blatantly untrue. I mean, it's not. Statistics describe how society on average acts, not how you personally act. Someone telling you "Statistically you're more likely to drown if you own a pool" doesn't mean as much if you bought a pool and then became a paraplegic, for example. Saying "emergency braking will bring down average car deaths" is probably true, but that might not make a difference for Joebob who drives his truck down empty County Road 230 once a week to check his mail.
- ceejayoz 3y agoJoebob’s car insurance premiums and taxes cover others’ car crashes. He is statistically impacted even if he’s a recluse without a car at all. (He might even be statistically more likely to run into the car he’s not used to seeing on the usually empty road via the stop sign he usually blows right through. Who knows?)
- dabluecaboose 3y ago> (He might even be statistically more likely to run into the car he’s not used to seeing on the usually empty road via the stop sign he usually blows right through. Who knows?) That's not how statistics work. Again, statistics mean little to the individual.
- ceejayoz 3y ago“You are statistically more likely to die prematurely and painfully if you eat polonium” sure matters to individuals who eat polonium. I don’t think you’re clear on the definition of “statistically”.
- dabluecaboose 3y agoI don't think you are clear on the definition of statistically. Citing things with >90% probability does not, actually, prove your weak point that "all statistical probabilities are individual certainties".
- withinboredom 3y ago> > Statistics are meaningless to the individual. > This is just blatantly untrue. This statement is blatently untrue. If a "driver gets in an accident every X miles/km" does that mean if you drive more than X miles, you're "overdue?" No, that's a statistical fallacy. Aggregate statistics are only meaningful if you're within a standard deviation of the mean. If you are a safe driver, it's likely to be meaningless. If you are a reckless driver, you're unlikely to live long enough to find out.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> If you are a safe driver, it's likely to be meaningless. No. You are sharing the road with others, of variable skill, and things like deer and pedestrians who can dart into traffic. I’ve been crashed into from behind while stopped in traffic; no fuckup on my end, but still would have likely benefited from automated emergency braking. Your car insurance also reflects others’ accident rates. You shoulder some of the medical and fire and police costs via taxes. Lots of statistical impact even in a perfect driver or someone who never drives at all.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- interroboink 3y agoI realize you already had some discussions on this point, but perhaps I can shed some light — I think your disagreements come down to a difference in interpretation of language. Here's one interpretation of "statistics are meaningless to the individual": If X makes people in general statistically more likely to do Y (such as "avoid accidents", in this case), it does not say anything about the effect it will have on a particular individual's behavior, such as you or me. In fact, it could very well make you or me less likely to do Y. As long as it averages out over the population, the statistic is still true. But you need to know the individual in order to know how X specifically affects them. I think you are taking a different/broader-scope interpretation of the statement. Something like: if X makes people in general (...as above), then given that we live in a society of various people, it will have some at least some impact, perhaps indirect, on all of us (c.f. your comments about taxes, insurance rates, etc). Maybe you got that already, but I'm a sucker for helping people be aware of when they're talking past each other (:
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]