4 ms·
The horrific reason for this figure is that owning a square in this ridiculous checkerboard is equivalent to owning 1/4 stake in the squares of public land that
by lolinder 3y ago
The horrific reason for this figure is that owning a square in this ridiculous checkerboard is equivalent to owning 1/4 stake in the squares of public land that it's adjacent to. If you own four black squares on the checkerboard on all sides of a single white square, you also own the white square, because you are the only person who can legally pass through onto the public land.
By citing this figure, the plaintiffs are essentially admitting that they are claiming de facto ownership over the public's land.
- hadlock 3y agoBy this logic of five squares, wouldn't that reduce the value by 20%
- lolinder 3y agoThis ranch apparently consists of quite a few squares in a complicated pattern, but even if it were just the four it wouldn't end up being exactly 20% because you would have to factor in the partial ownership of every adjacent public square, not just the one you surround completely.
- londons_explore 3y agoLooking at the map in the article, it looks like it is pretty much a checkerboard. Ie. Half is owned, half is not. So you'd expect a 50% reduction (minus a couple of percent for edge squares which are not yet enclosed)
- lolinder 3y agoWhich article has a map of this ranch? I've been looking but haven't found one. EDIT: I finally found maps in the opinion: https://www.wyd.uscourts.gov/sites/wyd/files/opinions/22-cv-67_SWS_Order.pdf https://www.wyd.uscourts.gov/sites/wyd/files/opinions/22-cv-...
- londons_explore 3y agoInset on the left, about a third of the way down It's a blurry map, but seems to show this ranch (in yellow)
- lolinder 3y agoOh, yeah, I saw that one, but I wouldn't try to draw any conclusions from it. It's a link to another article[0] that provides the map with a proper caption: > The area around Elk Mountain is surrounded by a checkerboard pattern of public (yellow) and private (white), as well as state (blue) lands. So the yellow is actually the public land, and it's unclear how much of the white is actually the ranch in question and how much is just other private land. [0] https://www.hcn.org/issues/54.3/north-public-lands-why-four-hunters-in-wyoming-were-charged-with-trespassing-on-land-they-never-touched https://www.hcn.org/issues/54.3/north-public-lands-why-four-...
- dkarp 3y agowow I didn't think they meant checkerboard pattern literally. I'd be interested to know why the land was partitioned that way across such a wide area
- themadturk 3y agoI remember looking at old Metsker maps of Washington counties when I was a kid and wondering about all those checkerboards of green and white land. My dad told me the green was public land, and couldn't really explain why it was divided that way. So it is, literally, divided up like a checkerboard. Wikipedia has an enlightening article on it [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Checkerboarding_(land) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Checkerboarding_(land)
- marssaxman 3y agoYou can see this pattern all across the west, a result of land grants meant to subsidize railroad development. The federal government platted all the land into sections, then gave every other section along each new rail corridor to the developer. The idea was to encourage the creation of higher-quality infrastructure, by motivating the railroad to increase the value of their land holdings, instead of simply laying track as cheaply as possible like they might do if they were paid by the mile.
- SideQuark 3y agoIt's reasonable the first infringing corner reduces the value more than the last, just like the first N miles reduce car value more than the last N
- seadan83 3y agoNot all land is of equal value. Having exclusive access to your own public area that is not going to be developed, could be that ammenity is worth a lot; further it makes the area effectively more contiguous. All is to say the sum can be worth more than the parts.
- anotherhue 3y agoThe property planning department must have been fans of Go.
- smithcoin 3y agoAh the board game. Took me way to long to figure out this wasn’t a subtle HN-dig at golang.
- jcpst 3y agoThose were the first two dots I was trying to connect as well.
- RajT88 3y agoEveryone I know who has tinkered with it loves it. I don't know how much I enjoy the language per se, but I went to a talk on Go once and ended up married to the organizer.
- dmoy 3y agoI dislike golang the least among languages I have to code. I generally don't like any programming language after I have tens of thousands of lines of it written
- anotherhue 3y agoI apologise for making such a generic joke
- jcpst 3y agoAll good. Generics are too new in Go for it to land.
- mcbrit 3y agoA checkerboard pattern is a horrifically inefficient way to claim territory in go. It might be useful to consider why checkerboards are good shape in legal systems, but bad shape in go. Also why the legal system rejected checkerboards after some thought, at least provisionally. (historical rant: You might as well resign if your opponent is not also 30k. Who comes up with these analogies? People who have barely heard of the game, like 10ks or sth?) Finally: yeah, Go is a bad analogy for this.
- irrational 3y agoOur backyard backs onto a green space. The only way someone can get to the green space is to walk through our backyard or parachute in. Effectively our yard goes from 1/2 acre to 1 acre when including the green space. Basically we have taken ownership of it since only we can access it. It is definitely a selling point for the house.
- hgsgm 3y agoApparently not anymore because corner crossers have precedent.
- ceejayoz 3y agoNo. This ruling doesn’t say you can walk through the backyard. If you can jump over it without touching the privately owned ground, it’s applicable.
- noitpmeder 3y agoBased on this ruling and the cited prior case law I would not want to take that to court. It's fairly clear that the govt will uphold public access to public land, with a fallback of eminent domain (seizure for fair compensation) of private land in order to facilitate public access. A prior case has a situation where the govt seized land to build a road to allow public access. The ruling was that the govt could not do such a thing without fair compensation.
- bombcar 3y agoWhat about the other 3 sides of the green space? Or does your backyard encircle it like an enclave?
- irrational 3y agoThere is a creek on one side. On the other side of the creek is more green space and another house. On either side of our house are other houses that back up to their own slices of the green space. Everyone has an agreement that we won’t go into anyone else’s part of the green space. Other people don’t have a way to access the green space without going through someone yard. Technically at either end they could get into the green space, but there is a forest without any paths and lots of blackberry plants and poison Ivy blocking the way. In all the years we’ve lived here, I’ve never seen anyone attempt it.
- prawn 3y agoHow did these checkerboards come about? I've noticed them on maps before when looking for public land in the US.
- not2b 3y agoIt has to do with the way the federal government granted land to the railroads to incentivize them to lay track. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Checkerboarding_(land) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Checkerboarding_(land)
- nine_k 3y agoIIRC, it was a way to push settlers farther to the West. Looked like a clever idea at the time, likely.
- lolinder 3y agoRailroad grants. The theory was that by granting land to railroads instead of money it incentivizes them to build the railroad well. By keeping half the land for the government the government profits from the increased value too. They just didn't think this far ahead.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think it was a sound policy. The problem is that the government never decided to sell the land. If they fold it to individuals, those people can put in easements to access their land but that never happened
- wkat4242 3y agoBut how were the railroads supposed to lay track from one of their squares to the next without this "corner crossing"?
- mannykannot 3y agoThe land on which the railroad was built was handled separately. This was land in the vicinity of the proposed railroad, which would increase significantly in value if and only if a functional railroad was completed.
- 2h 3y agoapparently you've never heard of an easement.
- xp84 3y agoIndeed, the actual buying of land in a checkerboard like this with this obvious intent is the most cynical, greedy thing, and I assume the only reason the government sold them the land in that pattern in the first place is because the rules allowing that were written by someone in the pocket of the folks looking to do this practice.
- lolinder 3y agoActually, it's a lot older than that and seems to have been an honest mistake. From the ruling [0]: > History and politics have complicated the pattern of land ownership in the West. To promote western expansion in the nineteenth century, the federal government encouraged the construction of rail lines through the West by granting every other 640-acre parcel along rail corridors to a railroad company. The hope was that the lands remaining with the government would increase in value as the companies built rail lines, which the government would later sell at high prices. The plan was successful further east, but the government struggled to sell the lands in the arid West. The result of this failed venture is the checkerboard pattern of public and private land that now plagues much of the West. [0] https://www.wyd.uscourts.gov/sites/wyd/files/opinions/22-cv-67_SWS_Order.pdf https://www.wyd.uscourts.gov/sites/wyd/files/opinions/22-cv-...
- donw 3y agoThing is, nobody in the right mind back in 1850 or whathaveyou would have thought of "walking across private land to get somewhere" as some sort of civil or criminal trespass. That's... how you got places. If you actually damaged something -- broke a fence, stole a horse, dug a ditch, whatever -- then, yeah, you'd get in trouble if you got caught. I heard from a friend that moved out to a rural area that especially the newcomers moving in from cities are super-sensitive about "their property". His neighbor -- from NYC -- threatened a lawsuit because my buddy's truck broke off some branches that extended out into the common road. Folks that have been living out there awhile are cautious with outsiders, but overall a lot more neighborly, just because you have to be.
- Someone 3y ago
- 4bpp 3y agoThere is some kind of hilarious circularity to this. It's almost comparable to founding a publicly-traded company which asserts that its principal source of profits will be shaking down doubters through the legal system, and then suing anyone who indeed expresses doubts for damages based on the expected loss in stock value if the company were to fail to bring or lose that very lawsuit. (Is this an appropriate model for certain "reputation economy" actions that exist in many human societies, like duels over perceived slights to one party's physical prowess?)
- Someone 3y agoIt is a bit easier with parcels that touch at corners, but that isn’t unique to using a checkerboard. With almost any way you cut land into parcels, people can surround a plot with land they own. Also, this doesn’t require a single owner to own those black squares. It could also be four individual owners, each building a (virtual or physical) wall on the border of their land. Because of that, I expect that any civilized country has laws that give land owners and their visitors the right to reach their land, so that they can benefit from owning it (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_of_way https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_of_way)
- mcv 3y agoAfter admitting this, the judge should fine the landowner the $7 million he illegally tried to appropriate.
- cbsmith 3y agoLike Go, but for landlords. ;-)