2 ms·
Honestly, I agree with every word here. I'd rather see conferences as networking events than quality filters. Conferences should invite published works. The con
by godelski 3y ago
Honestly, I agree with every word here. I'd rather see conferences as networking events than quality filters. Conferences should invite published works. The conference system just adds noise, and like you are suggesting, the single round results in a zero sum game and no advocates for the paper to be accepted/improved. Thus reviewers optimize their strategy: reject everything.
While I still have problems with peer review and still advocate for open publication, I do think many the the specific issues of ML could be resolved by focusing on journals rather than conferences.