4 ms·
Insurance companies are run by people that are good at statistics, and there is a fair chance that statistically this works out well but that does not mean anyt
by jacquesm 3y ago
Insurance companies are run by people that are good at statistics, and there is a fair chance that statistically this works out well but that does not mean anything for any particular individual. Chances are that EAB will cause some accidents and prevents a whole lot more, and that's enough for the insurers.
- peter422 3y agoEvery possible change to a car’s safety system will cause some deaths and save others… look at airbags. The aggregate stats are the most important things to look at, especially for something like AEB which has the ability to save pedestrians, which as of late are getting mowed down more and more frequently.
- jacquesm 3y agoAgreed that overall it can be an improvement. But I've clocked up a good 40K km since I got rid of the car that was equipped with defunct EAB and I'm fairly sure (but of course can not prove it) that I would have been in an accident by now on account of it triggering falsely. Conversely, I've never had a problem with airbags deploying without cause and my seatbelt is on just to move the car 10 meters because it is deeply ingrained and I refuse to drive - or be in - a car without it. But faulty EAB caused more trouble for me than any other safety feature to date and I really wonder what caused Mercedes Benz to release this feature in such a horrific functional state. It is beyond belief how broken it is and I would love to see their internal stats for how often their EAB caused - not prevented - single vehicle accidents.
- IanCal 3y agoAt the very least it sounds like people will benefit from actual tests and requirements about how the braking system must act.
- Olreich 3y agoThose would be good stats to mandate sharing with the proposed rules. Would likely cause them to rework the system if they started losing sales over it.
- ghostpepper 3y agoThere needs to be a tiered license then - if you pass the more rigorous exam you can drive cars without the extra "safety" features. Making AEB mandatory would increase the survival rate of poor drivers and punish people who actually pay attention on the road.
- IanCal 3y ago> and punish people who actually pay attention on the road. It can benefit people who have reaction times slower than silicon.
- ghostpepper 3y agoIt can also cause accidents, and some people go their whole lives without getting in an accident.
- IanCal 3y agoIncluding those that drive cars with aeb.
- sidewndr46 3y agoWasn't AIG an insurance company? They don't seem to be good at math, much less statistics.
- jacquesm 3y agoExceptions, rules and all that.
- caconym_ 3y ago> EAB will cause some accidents and prevents a whole lot more, and that's enough for the insurers. It should be enough for everybody on the road. People always say "don't be a statistic" but we are all part of these statistics whether we like it or not. AEB can also protect occupants of other vehicles, so using it or not is not a choice whose consequences only affect the individual making it.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoWhich is funny considering the explanation that was presented to me about why is it legal in the US to ride a motorcycle without a crash helmet. The explanation is: in case of an accident, the motorcycle driver has a lower chance to survive without the helmet. From the insurer’s perspective paying out a one time death insurance might be cheaper than paying someone money every month for the rest of their life. No idea how much truth is in that, though.
- drivebycomment 3y ago> why is it legal in the US to ride a motorcycle without a crash helmet. This depends on the state: https://www.cdc.gov/transportationsafety/calculator/factsheet/mchelmet.html https://www.cdc.gov/transportationsafety/calculator/factshee... > As of 2021, 18 states and the District of Columbia had universal motorcycle helmet laws, 29 states had laws requiring helmets for certain riders, and three states did not have any motorcycle helmet laws.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoWell, forgive me then. That’s the discussion I had back in 2016, when visiting the US the last time. Good to see there’s progress.