3 ms·
Ok, what are GitHub stars? I thought they rented space for git repos? (I'm paying them for that, at least). I've never used github to find repos and don't even
by nottorp 3y ago
Ok, what are GitHub stars? I thought they rented space for git repos? (I'm paying them for that, at least).
I've never used github to find repos and don't even know how, for public projects I've heard of them some other way and went to their github page if they were hosted there...
Do they have some social networking features that I've managed to ignore so far?
- dgacmu 3y agoIt's just the "click to favorite this repo" mechanism. It lets people track repos more easily ("see updates to started repos") and it's become a social gaming mechanism ("the most-starred deep learning cryptocurrency Blockchain mumble jumble on GitHub!")
- candiddevmike 3y agoYou need stars to ensure your open core marketing strategy is effective.
- EGreg 3y agoBingo. I realized it's all a game, when I worked developing facebook integrations at various digital agencies in 2010-2014 and they all bought tens of thousands of Facebook likes to kickstart the "organic" likes when they developed some app and campaign for a big brand. At the end the likes rang up, everyone was happy, got their Christmas bonus, etc. I am not sure how much the advertising industry isn't just a zero-sum thing just like the casinos and exchanges for stocks and crypto. For someone to win, someone else has to lose. And the house always takes a cut from everything lol.
- jacurtis 3y agoIt is a metric similar to a "like" on YouTube or Instagram or something. Github does more than just "rent space for git repos". It does do that, but there are two sides of GitHub. There is the legit CI/CD Git platform side, and then there is a social network of code side. The stars are a mechanism that contribute to the social network side of github. There are basically three metrics on GitHub: 1. Stars - Akin to "likes" on other platforms, or favorites, or hearts. They represent a thumbsup, or a soft-bookmark to find a project later. Indicates appreciation or interest in a repo/project. These are the most common form of karma or metric on Github 2. Watch - This is like following a specific repo. You can get updates when a new release is made, pull requests are made, issues are submitted, etc.. It expresses deeper interest in a project/repo because you want to see updates as they happen. 3. Follows - These happen at the account level. So you can follow an entire organization or developer and see everything they do. This is like subscribing to someone on YouTube or following them on Instagram. You want to see more projects and updates for them in your feed. All these metrics combine into an internal "SEO" on GitHub search (and Google search). So stars actually do tangibly contribute to the likelihood of a project being discovered by strangers. Which is what gives them value. The author also points out that having a lot of stars is often perceived as being more trustworthy of a project. This is an intangible benefit that the author was expressing he wanted to test. However, as the author stated, this is a bad metric in practice, but it doesn't mean that other people don't perceive it that way. Similar to a twitter account with a 100,000 followers, you will assume is more noteworthy/trustworthy/prominent than someone with 1,000 followers. This is not necessarily the case, which is similar to how it works on github as well. It is often perceived this way, although it shouldn't be.
- nottorp 3y ago> Similar to a twitter account with a 100,000 followers, you will assume is more noteworthy/trustworthy/prominent than someone with 1,000 followers. I'd assume they're better at catering to the lowest common denominator tbh. As for libraries/project trying to solve a technical problem, I'd look for 3rd parties saying they're using them and how it's going for them. Definitely wouldn't trust "stars".
- halostatue 3y agoStars also can act as bookmarks to projects. There are tools out there (https://github.com/simonecorsi/mawesome https://github.com/simonecorsi/mawesome is the one I use for my private stars list) which can take your stars and turn them into a markdown file.
- justinclift 3y ago> It is a metric similar to a "like" ... They used to be described as a "bookmark" for a repo, same as browsers do for web pages. Thinking that over a bit more, it's still probably the more accurate mental picture of what they're for vs a "like". But, that might just be me. :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- PurpleRamen 3y agoStars are akin to a like on youtube, which seems to be used in the social game of github. If there is a metric, there will be people worshiping it, and the same is true for those stars. Though, I'm not sure how big the impact of them really is. For example, there is https://github.com/trending https://github.com/trending where you will see how many new stars the popular projects gained today.
- justrealist 3y agoIf I'm deciding between open-source libraries, choosing the library with 12 stars is far riskier than choosing the library with 2,500 stars. I know it's not a perfect measure but I don't have infinite time to spend researching every choice I make, and this is (for now) a pretty reasonable heuristic that a library is maintained and has eyeballs on it.
- drexlspivey 3y agoI’ve been using stars as bookmarks instead of likes. A lot of times I’ll encounter a problem and remember that there was some software that solves it and go through my starred repos to find it. Guess I’m in the minority
- PurpleRamen 3y agoYou are not alone with this. It's probably even the original purpose of it, considering that some browsers use star-icon for their bookmarks. And GitHub even supports this by having lists for managing starred repos.