4 ms·
> If you are going to use someone else's work in order to make something that you are going to profit off of, I believe that original author should be compensat
by lmm 3y ago
> If you are going to use someone else's work in order to make something that you are going to profit off of, I believe that original author should be compensated. And should also be able to decide they don't want their work used in that way.
> Note that I'm not talking about what existing copyright law says; I'm talking about how I believe we should be regulating this new facet of the industry.
Is it really new? Humans have always learnt by studying what's out there already. Our whole culture is built on what's been done and published before (and how could it be otherwise?). Without Bach there would be no Mozart, and then down the line their influence permeates everything you hear today.
If anything I'd like to make it easier to reuse parts of our shared culture, and limit the ability of organisations to control how things that they've published are reused. You can make private works if you want to keep control of them, but at some point the public deserves to share and rework the things that have been pushed into the public consciousness.
- otabdeveloper4 3y ago> Humans have always learnt by studying what's out there already. Our whole culture is built on what's been done and published before Are you implying that educators should not be compensated or credited? Because that is not how it works in the real world.
- inkblotuniverse 3y agoIf I read a lot of fantasy books as a kid, then start writing my own fantasy book, should I have to pay royalties to the authors of the books I read?
- Mordisquitos 3y agoDoes your ability to write fantasy books absolutely depend on having read those fantasy books as a kid? Was gaining the ability to write your own fantasy books and profit from them your only motivation to read those fantasy books? After gaining the ability to write fantasy books thanks to having read them, can you now produce fantasy books at a qualitatively different speed, scale, and conditions than any of the authors of the books that you read? If the answer to those three questions is "yes", then I would argue that yes, you absolutely should have to pay royalties to the authors.
- realusername 3y ago> If the answer to those three questions is "yes", then I would argue that yes, you absolutely should have to pay royalties to the authors. Copyright lobbies can't have their own cake and eat it too, if you want to enforce such a different way of thinking about copyright compared to the current one, that would destroy the current industry and rightly so.
- Mordisquitos 3y agoI would appreciate if you addressed the questions as literally stated. I could just as well argue that businesses developing or making use of LLMs can't have their cake and eat it too. If they want their computer programs to enjoy the same rights and prerogatives as human creators do, they should be ready to demonstrate that those models are truly moral agents, with their own lived experiences, and thus deserve the status of legal persons as of themselves subject to the same laws and obligations as human beings.
- realusername 3y ago> If they want their computer programs to enjoy the same rights and prerogatives as human creators do I don't think they care about that, they seems fine with output images not being copyrightable as per the current legislation.
- henearkr 3y agoThey already paid when they bought the books. Why would they need to pay more?
- Mordisquitos 3y agoSay I want to write a screenplay and produce the resulting film, for profit, but I am literally unable to have any ideas whatsoever unless I base them on book that I read. With this in mind, and with this sole motivation, I buy and read the whole collection of Brandon Sanderson's novels and create a screenplay based exclusively on their content, for I have no ideas nor experiences of my own. I already paid when I bought the books. Why would I need to pay Brandon Sanderson any more?
- otabdeveloper4 3y agoYes, you do. The royalty is usually called a "college degree". Most jobs require a degree or certification of some sort.
- qwytw 3y ago> Because that is not how it works in the real world. Unless you're satirizing it or making fun of it in some other way. Then it's fair use..
- lmm 3y agoEducators get paid a flat fee, not an indenture on your future work (nor do you owe anything back to the people who made the learning materials they use). And if you teach yourself from books or websites you don't pay anything (except maybe the cost of the books). All of which seems right and proper?
- basisword 3y ago>> Is it really new? Humans have always learnt by studying what's out there already. "Humans" being the important word here. I don't understand why people keep trying to compare training a model to humans learning through reading etc. They are very different things. Learning done by machines at enormous scale and done to benefit private companies financially is not the same as humans learning.
- pas 3y ago> They are very different things Yes, but also very similar. We learn very well by spaced repetition, and by practicing things. Our whole nervous system stores information in a similar way. Is the brain and the individual neurons more complex? Yes, sure, but that doesn't negate the core similarities. > Learning done by machines at enormous scale and done to benefit private companies financially is not the same as humans learning. Yes, that's the important difference. That in the end if you train a robot you get a program that's easy to copy/scale, the marginal cost of using it is orders of magnitude lower than what you'd get if you would do it with humans in the loop. We already have fair use in copyright, because there are important differences between the various forms and modalities of human imitation. And of course maybe it's time to rename copyright to usageright. After current copyright doesn't even apply in most cases. (The results are not derivatives, there's sufficient substantial transformative difference, etc. That said, the phrasing in the US constitution still makes sense: "... the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and ..." ... if we interpret Right to mean all rights, including even the right of who can read/see it.)
- BrandonLive 3y agoHow is it meaningfully different with respect to this question? If I go to a museum and look at a bunch of modern paintings, then go home and paint something new but “in the style of”, this is well-established as within my rights, regardless of how any of the painters whose work I studied and was inspired by might feel. If I take a notebook and write down some notes about the themes and stylistic attributes of what I see, then go home and paint something in the same style, that too is fine - right? Or would you argue the notes I took are a copyright violation? Or the works I made using those notes? Now let’s say I automate the process of recording those notes. Does that change the fundamentals of what is happening, with respect to copyright? Personally, I don’t think so.
- dbspin 3y ago> You can make private works if you want to keep control of them, but at some point the public deserves to share and rework the things that have been pushed into the public consciousness. There's already a licensing framework for artists doing this - should they wish to. It's called Creative Commons, and allows a pretty fine distinction of rights from public domain to free for personal use not commercial, and everything in between. https://creativecommons.org/ https://creativecommons.org/ I agree our shared culture in some sense ultimately owns the productions of the culture. But that's wildly different to (and in some senses the opposite of) letting private companies enclose, privatise and sell those products back to us. As for example Disney has done over and over again, taking myths transcribed by the Brothers Grimm, or classic novels now in the public domain, 'reinterpreting' them and viciously enforcing copyright on these new interpretations. The entire point of copyright law is to allow the Bach's of this world to profit from their work - without having to die in poverty and obscurity, as so many artists and musicians have historically, even while others have profited from their work at scale. > Humans have always learnt by studying what's out there already. Finally - as other commentators have noted, there's really no similarity at all between a human at human pace studying and integrating understanding of a piece or genre of art, and an AI training to replicate that work at scale as perfectly as possible. A much better comparator would be the Chinese factory 'villages' that reproduce paintings at scale for the commercial market, without creativity or 'art' being a part of the process. But even that is a poor analogy, since individual humans mediate the process. A really good analogy would be a giant food corporation like Nestle somehow scanning the product of a restaurant and then offering that chefs unique dishes that had taken years to invent for nearly free - using the same name and benefiting from the association.
- HPsquared 3y agoWhat if the AI is open source and run by individual creators? That changes the slant of the argument a lot. I worry that excessive regulation will mostly come down on individual creators using AI tools.
- dbspin 3y agoI'm not sure what you mean? The image and text models currently becoming popular are being trained on work that is not owned or created by those creating the models. The consensus amongst the artists whose work is being used to train them (without their permission or compensation) is very high that this is a bad thing. Financial impacts are already being felt by artists across industries. There's a huge level of denial of the impact of this on professional artists, already today, here on hacker news. 'Open source' is a separate issue to training on other peoples work, replicating their style and stealing their livelihood.
- ChuckkH 3y ago"Humans have always learnt by studying what's out there already." Neither an AI model nor an AI developer who programs that model are actually studying "what's out there already". One is copying files, and the other is running algorithms on copied files. And then the first one is raking in $$$ while bankrupting the authors of those files. That's illegal in the US, UK, EU and under the terms of the Berne Convention.