> So suddenly Yudkowsky is the Thought Leader and a punching bag I only meant to imply the latter. I suppose I inadvertently applied the former by mentioning h

> So suddenly Yudkowsky is the Thought Leader and a punching bag I only meant to imply the latter. I suppose I inadvertently applied the former by mentioning him juxtaposed to Noam Chomsky and Michael Moore, although it is a stretch for me to even see those two as "Thought Leaders" in the present day. Chomsky is some weird kind of anarcho-syndicalist and Michael Moore seemed to fade away during the Obama years. Neither are really "leading" anything these days. > A week or two ago ... Yudkowsky was apparently a Complete Nobody. There is nothing contradicting being a punching bag and a complete nobody. It's like a D-list actor whose entire career is to get his ass kicked by the hero in action movies. Or the B-tier heel in professional wrestling. You might eventually recognize his face and he may even achieve some cult-status fame. Their whole purpose is to display the might of the eventual hero so we often allow them to embody some apparent strength so that a sense of risk for the hero is maintained. Yudkowski makes for a juicy target. For example /r/sneerclub has been around since 2015! The fact that the mainstream media has now identified him as a magnet for derision isn't surprising. No one has to know who he is. They just take one look at him, hear a couple of sentences from his mouth and they immediately form a strong opinion on his character. > The mainstream interest only really picked up in the last half a year. But somehow he's in on it. What do you mean "he's in on it"? I'm suggesting he is an unwitting participant. I have no doubt he actually believes he is the main character. He doesn't lack the ego for that. FWIW, even though I personally really dislike Yudkowski as a person - I believe he has some interesting points to make. And frankly, it bugs me that he is so often dismissed without deep engagement with his arguments. But he is so lacking in media training and social skills that he is easily misdirected to look like the exact foolish/cartoonish caricature the media wants. Even in friendly podcast situations he comes off as unhinged. And I honestly believe that boosting the signal of characters like Yudkowski is part of the mainstream establishments playbook for dealing with dissent. In comparison, Sam Altman's "aw shucks" performance in front of the senate, with favorable sound bites where he boyishly claims to have no financial stake in OpenAI, was positively wholesome.