6 ms·
Tesla-supported accounts, please give your excuse by number: 1. It's not the current production model. 2. The driver should have been paying attention. 3. We
by Animats 3y ago
Tesla-supported accounts, please give your excuse by number:
1. It's not the current production model.
2. The driver should have been paying attention.
3. We're not sure self-driving was on.
4. It's a beta version.
5. The correct measurement of hazard is some other metric that makes Tesla look better.
5. "No new technology has been fully accepted by society until it has killed someone".
- oh_sigh 3y ago2. How exactly does one miss a 40' long, 10' tall truck that is emblazoned with flashing lights?
- modernpacifist 3y agoBy not reading past the word "Autopilot" in the product description and ticking the Accept Terms box instead of having their personal lawyer review it, like the rest of us do.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y ago> instead of having their personal lawyer review it, like the rest of us do. Wait, do you all have personal lawyers that you pay to review every (or any) EULA you accept? I clearly do not make enough money to hang out on this site.
- qwytw 3y agoWell I generally find it much harder to remain attentive when using an autopilot. I assume I'm not unique in the regard (i.e. it's an "autopilot" but technically you must pay as much attention to what happening if you were driving yourself. What would be the point of such feature? Well.. obviously companies obviously bring this up when something bad happens and not in their marketing material).
- oh_sigh 3y agoThe problem is the car doesn't let you ignore it. You need to perform some kind of "hey, are you paying attention?" input on the steering wheel what seems like every 30 seconds or so(not sure of the exact numbers). Maybe the driver just happened to doze off in that intervening 30 seconds...at which point, he would have crashed anyway.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hospitalJail 3y agoHey you know we aren't allowed to mention our pro-corporate astroturfing here! It is kind of mind boggling its against the rules to discuss that billion dollar companies might make accounts to drive sales/help their reputation. I've seen small companies doing it. I think its foolish to ignore that big companies can do it so well, its basically impossible to prove.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> mind boggling its against the rules to discuss that billion dollar companies might make accounts to drive sales/help their reputation It's against the rules because it's boring and impossible to prove. Just downvote/flag and move on.
- dingusdew 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anonporridge 3y ago7. I don't give a fuck that fatal accidents happen and are caused by self driving cars. It would be insane to think it would be otherwise. Humans kill 1.35 million people while driving cars globally every year. We're terrible drivers. If I see data that a global fleet of self driving cars will only kill 1.30 million people instead of the current human driven standard of 1.35, then I'm going to continue to rabidly support the transition and heap shame on the heads of any luddites who resist with faulty emotional appeals, who therefore are indirectly supporting the status quo of unnecessary pain and suffering. We absolutely should hold self driving cars to a standard higher than human drivers, but that's not a very high bar. And a handful of anecdotal cases don't give us any useful data to compare and contrast the two options.
- rurp 3y agoSo you must be pretty down on Tesla given their refusal to release anything but the most cherry picked data to backup their grand safety claims, right?
- anonporridge 3y agoAbsolutely. It's reprehensible that they don't.
- petilon 3y agoIt is not sufficient if, in aggregate, self-driving cars have fewer accidents. If you lose a loved one in an accident where the accident could have been easily avoided if a human was driving, then you're not going to be mollified to hear that in aggregate, fewer people are being killed by self-driving cars! You'd be outraged to hear such a justification! The expectation therefore is that in each individual injury accident a human clearly could not have handled the situation any better. Self-driving cars have to be significantly better than humans to be accepted by society.
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoWell this is actually that exact situation. The driver was supposed to be driving.
- aeternum 3y ago1,2,4,5. Now what is your excuse for the 4,285 human-driver caused fatalities that occurred in CA alone in 2021? How about the 1,370 caused by those driving under the influence?
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoHis excuse is that he hates Elon Musk so he's throwing whatever hate he can his way.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoIf you don't have at least hostility & contempt for musk something is wrong with your soul.
- sidibe 3y agoTbf there are some people, actually most people, who don't know enough about him and his grift, and the media played along with his Iron Man image for a long time. But on a site like this? They must know.
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoLol. Contempt for a guy for what? Being successful and occasionally saying stupid things? I'm sure you've never said anything stupid
- giraffe_lady 3y agoYes I truly do not like it when people are successful at applying their incredible power to making the world worse. I’ve said stupid things I’ve never aided a fascist movement though but hey maybe it’s all the same thing in the end right.
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoWhat did he do that was fascist?
- martythemaniak 3y agoWhat's a Tesla-supported account? Is it anyone who doesn't share HN echo-chamber hate for Tesla, likes their products and thinks they have a great future? If so, where should I go collect my earnings?
- timeon 3y ago> echo-chamber hate Was HN echo-chamber killing on the road? Was it?
- enslavedrobot 3y agoWas the autopilot in this 2014 Tesla built by a third party company owned by Intel? Is that tech deployed in 50 million cars? Is it!? Did Tesla cut ties with them because they refused to share data? Did they!?
- cmiles74 3y agoDon't forget "It's safer than any human driver anyway."
- cracrecry 3y ago6. It is going to get better over time. What Tesla does is record every single accident and incident, with video and with Telemetry. That means that we learn over time. We did that with airplanes, going from being the highest risk vehicles to travel with to being the safest. Every time an accident happens we learn something that we can use to improve the system. Not just the car, but also the roads and procedures. For example, This accident has a strange vehicle on the road: A firetruck, probably the firetruck could have done better. In the accidents involving the median of the road, the maintenance people had also responsibility removing the signs that should be there.
- kaba0 3y agoIt is literally orders of magnitude harder to commute on roads than flying, and is very likely GAI territory. This cute little robot vacuum logic won’t cut it and won’t be better on its own.
- Animats 3y agoI'm amused that there are stories for both "self driving cars are impossible", and "there are too many Waymo self driving cars on the streets in my neighborhood".
- enslavedrobot 3y ago8. This car didn't have the self driving feature. It was built before FSD existed and uses Mobileye technology. They are owned by Intel and have their technology in BMWs Nissan, Geely, Toyota, Nio etc etc. Your hate boner is showing.