4 ms·
What's it doing crashing off of the west coast of Korea? If you're trying for orbit, don't you usually launch east, so that you get a boost from earth's rotati
by AnimalMuppet 3y ago
What's it doing crashing off of the west coast of Korea? If you're trying for orbit, don't you usually launch east, so that you get a boost from earth's rotation? Or did the rocket just malfunction that badly? (Or is the article just wrong on that detail? Or did I read it wrong?)
- Alupis 3y agoA guess would be to avoid Japanese airspace, who promised to shoot down anything flying overhead. That assumes this rocket was actually intended to reach orbit and deposit a real satellite. It seems very ambitious to try to park a satellite in orbit on your very first orbital rocket. Unless I'm missing something?
- BWStearns 3y agoThey've gotten a couple sats to orbit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unha https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unha
- ancientworldnow 3y agoThey put their first satellite in orbit in 2012 confirmed by NORAD. This is not the first launch of a satellite, only a "spy satellite." Honestly, feels like a concerted media effort to stoke panic about North Korea. Japan and South Korea acted like they didn't know was happening publicly (alarms etc) despite being informed of the launch publicly days before as reported in the media.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago> Japan and South Korea acted like they didn't know was happening publicly (alarms etc) despite being informed of the launch publicly days before as reported in the media. They may have known it was happening, but once the launch malfunctioned, they didn't know where it was going.
- bink 3y agoAnd I don't think either side trusts the other when they say "we're launching a rocket near you but not at you".
- bonestamp2 3y agoNot to mention, they have to trust that they're actually telling the truth because it's basically an ICBM with a satellite as a payload (instead of an explosive weapon). Heck, it could still be both. Since it's a hostile party launching it, they have to treat it as if it's a weapon before it even launches (such as warning they'll shoot it down if it's in their airspace).
- oh_sigh 3y agoTheir launch complex is in the far west of the country, and directly east does cross over portions of Korea Bay(/Yellow Sea). Or, I guess, they could have been going for a polar orbit. 39.65974870373334, 124.70613853508173
- wkat4242 3y agoIt was launched from Tonghae which is in the east right?
- oh_sigh 3y agoTonghae is in the far east, but per the article it was launched from Sohae Satellite Launching Ground.
- wkat4242 3y agoOh strange, in the news here it said Tonghae-Ri. Thanks! Edit: Aha I see it, I looked it up and it says it is from Tongchang-ri which is where Sohae is, not Tonghae. This was what confused me. Little knowledge + too much wikipedia + assumptions = fake news :P
- dylan604 3y agonah, fake news wouldn't have printed the correction and just doubled down on it
- xoa 3y ago>If you're trying for orbit, don't you usually launch east, so that you get a boost from earth's rotation? No, or rather it's somewhat more complicated. Yes there are many popular orbits (or deep space) where that's an advantage, but there are also lots of orbits where it's less so or even outright undesirable such as with polar orbits. Depending on the purpose of the launch in question it may be necessary to cancel out that energy which means it's actively more expensive to have it. Locations far from the equator get less either way and have to take that into account. Launch safety is critical too as well, nobody wants to have debris from a failed launch come down somewhere undesirable. For civilized countries that's anywhere that might cause damage, but even for dictatorships it'd include other countries they don't want to offend that specific way or alternatively to give insights into whatever they are launching that could come from wreckage analysis (failure in low first stage isn't going to mean stuff burns up like a deorbit). So even when a target orbit would indeed benefit from such a directly easterly launch, a dog leg is often part of it. Obviously NK is less than transparent about all this but the basic incentives are still there.
- dylan604 3y ago>For civilized countries that's anywhere that might cause damage Trying to find a joke for that applied to SpaceX/Starship.
- kryptiskt 3y agoSpy satellites are launched to highly inclined orbits (think passing over the poles) so they can cover the whole of the Earth and slightly against the Earth's rotation so they can be sun-synchronous[0]. So this is just what you would expect from such a satellite. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun-synchronous_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun-synchronous_orbit
- Rebelgecko 3y agoFor some high inclination orbits (like if you want a polar orbit that covers the whole world) it might make sense to launch in a NNW or SSW direction. Even for lower inclinations, sometimes it's easier for geopolitical reasons. IIRC Israel always launches retrograde over the sea to avoid upsetting their neighbors, could be similar with NK