3 ms·
I think the point is that shallow references and use of Nazi images in ad hominem attacks does does not contribute meaningfully to any discussion. If you want
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
I think the point is that shallow references and use of Nazi images in ad hominem attacks does does not contribute meaningfully to any discussion.
If you want to use the Holocaust to draw a comparison, it should have substance. Without substance, anyone can make shallow comparisons.
- CodeWriter23 3y agoI think the point is to make it not ok to call powers practicing racism and genocide out for being nazi-like.
- cubefox 3y agoThe Auschwitz museum would probably not have complained about death camp analogies when the comparison was an actual genocide. But that was very far from the case.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoAre we expecting the auschwitz museum to universally and perfectly predict and oppose fomenting genocides? Is that a role they're willing and competent to perform for us? Is that where we want that responsibility to solely reside?
- cubefox 3y agoThe situation here was pretty clear cut.
- autokad 3y agowho decides what is substance?
- s1artibartfast 3y agoWhat I meant by substance is that there is some effort to actually explain a comparison and thought. Not just a statement of fact or reference. Essentially making a case. What I mean is different than accuracy. You could write an essay or book comparing something to Nazism, and be right or wrong, but at least you're making a case. If you're just claiming a comparison without presenting a case, you can also be right or wrong, but you're not doing anything more than throwing a name around and making an ad hominem attack.
- autokad 3y agoic, makes sense. unfortunately political ads are just that. Even if they wanted to, people don't like being bothered with explanations
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI agree. Therefore I encourage people to have to have disdain for Nazi / Holocaust comparisons in political ads. It simply pollutes the discourse and makes it more difficult to actually learn valuable lessons from the Holocaust
- gumby 3y agoAs I noted I agree that that was likely and understandably the museum's thinking. My point is that such shallow ad hominem (or ad generim in that case) reference were precisely how Germany traveled down the path it did. I didn't say the museum should not have objected. I feel they could have used the episode for greater value/understanding.