4 ms·
Yes, yes the UK's swivel-eyed loons have a point. But - outside of performative activism and spleen-venting - do they have any interest in sustained or intelli
by bell-cot 3y ago
Yes, yes the UK's swivel-eyed loons have a point.
But - outside of performative activism and spleen-venting - do they have any interest in sustained or intelligent actions which might address a few of the problems?
On paper, the UK's Liberal Democratic Party sounds like the perfect place for people alarmed by a creepy, authoritarian state. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_Democrats_(UK)#Ideology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_Democrats_(UK)#Ideolog... ) Wikipedia says the Liberal Dem. Party had under 75,000 members in 2021 (a touch over 0.1% of the UK's population). The next UK general election - where their nearly-all-powerful Parliament will be elected - must happen by 28 Jan 2025.
Anyone up for actually doing stuff?
EDIT: Yes, the LD's have at least as much of a "Faithless Elector" problem as any political party. How much of that is due to their party having a micro-membership, and the voters having no attention spans nor memories? Vs. (example) back in the "golden era" of America's National Rifle Association - the NRA kept "forever" records on how every congressman voted on every bill of interest to the NRA, and gave their loyal members "scorecards" on the candidates before every election. NRA Membership was ~1% of America's population...but Congressmen who didn't want to become ex-Congressmen generally thought very, very hard before they voted against the NRA on anything related to guns.
- Taywee 3y agoYeah, I've got the same question, and I see the same trend in American political issues. There's an obvious problem, and the left-leaning want to try to solve it by either increasing power and control of one (usually governmental) group or decreasing the power and control of a group (like the police). The right leaning ones protest this desire, but tend to not provide any ideas or solutions at all. They claim the problem is unsolvable, or not a problem, or often that it doesn't even exist. I get the paranoia, but where are your solutions? Wouldn't it be more effective to instead come up with a fix that you prefer?
- msla 3y ago> The right leaning ones protest this desire, but tend to not provide any ideas or solutions at all. I think we can all look at places like Florida to see what the right has in mind, and it certainly isn't reducing the size or intrusiveness of government.
- ajmurmann 3y agoIt would be nice if these policies could be part of the campaigns, rather than just ranting against the other party's plan. Let's be upfront about possible policies and compare those. I get that things might change as rubber hits the road, but typically we get heavily watered-down versions of proposals and don't start out with nothing to reason about to begin with and then get the policy.
- msla 3y agoMy point is that things are happening right now in Florida, and the guy in charge of Florida is the one the GOP establishment apparently wants as their Presidential candidate next year. Florida is, therefore, pretty close to what the GOP's vision for the future looks like, were the GOP in charge of the whole country. It couldn't really get any clearer.
- boredumb 3y agoI actually don't agree about the point you make about american politics. I think the left wing "solutions" are broadcasted on entertainment and media channels a lot louder where as the right wing "solutions" are generally silo'd and not propagated in a "mainstream" fashion (or just to be lampooned) so the perception is one side loudly demanding things and the others simply protesting it. The spectrum of opinions and solutions from people on both sides seems to be massive at a grassroots level but there are massive interests involved in the media distilling them into two camps of people with zero nuance.
- Taywee 3y agoThis isn't just my perspective from media, but from living in a city with a very conservative base (Colorado Springs). I've seen very little political action from conservatives that wasn't reactionary and to the tone of "actually, we don't want anything to change, anywhere at all, unless it means legally enforcing my religious ideals". When it comes to major issues like "how do we handle this virus?" I haven't seen any answers at all from the right other than "we don't want anything the other side of the fence wants". How does the right plan to handle many of the largest problems? Food monoculture? Environmental problems? Wealth inequality? Racial inequality? I live in a pool of conservatism, and the answer is always "what's the problem? My life is good."
- boredumb 3y ago> Food monoculture? Environmental problems? Wealth inequality? Racial inequality? Wealth inequality: reducing regulatory capture and ease of doing business to encourage more competition and wealth across all levels of industry. Food monoculture: reducing globalization of trade and exports to focus on local farming and agriculture Environmental problems: reducing globalization of trade and exports to reduce shipping and much worse pollution and environmental damage in countries of origin (while also promoting manufacturing here to help with wealth inequality) Racial inequality: of what?* *edit now that I re-read it, I mean what particular race and inequality are we addressing, there are plenty and there is no blanket solution.
- 3y ago
- tonfreed 3y agoFrom the amount of Ted Kascynski memes I see circle around the right wing internet, I'd probably start paying more attention to what they're actually saying without the filter of partisan bloggers.
- easytiger 3y ago> On paper, the UK's Liberal Democratic Party sounds like the perfect place for people alarmed by a creepy, authoritarian state. They were pro lockdown (even after the basis was undermined in 2021) and gain most of their MPs from local issues such as promising to stop the building of housing estates etc. They have no political agenda that is in anyway related to their historical basis
- Veen 3y agoThe problem with the LibDems is the gap between what they say and what they do. The reason they are in such dire straits is that when they got a sniff of power and joined a coalition with the Tories, they abandoned a number of key election promises and royally pissed off their core vote. (And when they were punished in the polls for this, their leader quit and got a job as Facebook's amoral bullshitter in chief.) Plus, the LibDems support all the amoral creepy shit, anyway. Unfortunately, it's got cross-party support, as has the Online Safety Bill.
- dmix 3y agoHas there ever been a political party that wasn’t a disappointment once in power in the last few decades? You basically have to choose the least bad options.
- dsign 3y agoI don't get why we put up with political parties at all... is it to have somebody to blame, somebody who is not ourselves? Because, if it wasn't so, we would enact direct democracy, and the next time that a lobby group wants to pocket a politician, it would have to pocket each and every single citizen...which I guess they could do by paying voluntary taxes...
- Veen 3y agoIf we had direct democracy in the UK, immigration would be banned, Brexit would have happened in the 1980s, and murderers and child molesters would be hanged.
- Ntrails 3y ago- yes and no, I suspect you would see a stricter system with numerical limits. Aus is often touted as a good example - the EEC would have stayed as just that, I suspect. Perhaps the EU would have formed without us, hard to know. - yup
- Analemma_ 3y ago
- danjac 3y ago> UK's Liberal Democratic Party sounds like the perfect place for people alarmed by a creepy, authoritarian state. Which presumably explains why their leader Nick Clegg went off to work for the not at all creepy and authoritarian Facebook.
- yodelshady 3y ago> But - outside of performative activism and spleen-venting - do they have any interest in sustained or intelligent actions which might address a few of the problems? Well, that would like under the purview of your conundrums of political science, not stuff for the hoi polloi. You don't want a tyranny of the majority, but - I believe this is the point being made - just dismissing popular concerns which have at least a grain of truth will bite you in the arse and take down not just your one pet project, but everything else even vaguely connected. Ultimately here that means solving some thornier problems, because it is an amazing but accurate stereotype these days that the person riding a bike in most cities is more privileged than the person driving. The former could afford a nice place in the city, which is way more than the cost of car ownership - and almost certainly relied on nepotism in some way. To fix that, alternative transit to suburbs NEED to exist, even in the face of negligent or outright malicious government. Accommodation in cities NEEDS to be cheaper, something I'm not sure has ever happened without urban decay and collapse. And lastly, crime, in cities and on transit, NEEDS to be controlled at relatively low levels - yes, even if the perpetrators are minorities. I have to really strongly disagree with the idea that automation makes the law less fair. That's a cheap shot, the progressive's equivalent of "think of the children". High crime areas are not romantic anti-racist utopias where the downtrodden mix rap with ceilidhs. They are shit, they are devastating to any real investment and growth, they hold no opportunity whatsoever to any decent person of any ethnicity, and discussion of policing shouldn't ignore that.
- floren 3y ago> Ultimately here that means solving some thornier problems, because it is an amazing but accurate stereotype these days that the person riding a bike in most cities is more privileged than the person driving. The former could afford a nice place in the city, which is way more than the cost of car ownership - and almost certainly relied on nepotism in some way. During the pandemic SF closed a section of Great Highway, a road that runs along the ocean in the Sunset district, so people could get out and exercise on it and not have to get close to others. Now, Great Highway is also one of the fastest ways to go north-south through the area. I met one guy who lived in Sunset who was welding up caltrops to throw on the road if it was reopened to car traffic. Surely those noble caltrops would know better than to puncture the tires of a single mother driving in from out of town to work at his local coffee shop, though. Talk about privilege.
- mschuster91 3y agoThe UK has the same problem as the US: it's effectively a two-party system, with a majority of the votes going to the large Tory and Labour block. For example, in the 2019 election 11.5% voted for LibDem, and instead of the 74 seats they'd have gained in a proportionally fair system as the German Bundestag, they got 11 of 650.
- llimos 3y agoNick Clegg was the leader of the Liberal Democrats, and Deputy Prime Minister. He then swanned off to become VP of Facebook. I'm not saying it should tell you everything you need to know, but a large part, yes.