4 ms·
> I want all e-fuses to be banned, as well as any other means for manufacturers to permanently reduce, restrict, or remove functionality from products after the
by JohnFen 3y ago
> I want all e-fuses to be banned, as well as any other means for manufacturers to permanently reduce, restrict, or remove functionality from products after they've been sold.
I am in opposition to this stance. What you're (rightfully) concerned about is when companies do bad things with these mechanisms. But the mechanisms themselves not only have no ethical/moral problems, but are also really useful for all sorts of things that entirely unobjectionable.
- josephcsible 3y agoWhat legitimate uses are there for e-fuses that can't be done just as well with arbitrarily rewritable storage?
- JohnFen 3y agoMany security applications, situations where you're providing equipment to others and want to make sure it's not modified, etc. It's not that hard to come up with legitimate uses for this. In any case, that sortof doesn't matter. Even if there was no legitimate use for them, that doesn't in and of itself mean they should be illegal. You should at the least demonstrate that their existence is causing great societal harm.
- josephcsible 3y ago> Many security applications, situations where you're providing equipment to others and want to make sure it's not modified, etc. It's not that hard to come up with legitimate uses for this. Why isn't just making sure the expected private key didn't get wiped a good enough way of making sure it's not modified? > You should at the least demonstrate that their existence is causing great societal harm. Okay, how about that it destroys the secondhand CPU market? Once you use an AMD CPU in a Lenovo computer, it blows e-fuses to keep you from ever using it in any other brand of computer: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29958247 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29958247
- JohnFen 3y ago> Why isn't just making sure the expected private key didn't get wiped a good enough way of making sure it's not modified? What's to stop someone from extracting and restoring the private key? > Okay, how about that it destroys the secondhand CPU market? Sure, then how about addressing that issue rather than proposing to outlaw an entire mechanism entirely? We have a lot of things that can be misused, but (generally) only in extreme cases do we outlaw the tech itself. More usually, we have laws targeting the misuse of the tech.
- josephcsible 3y ago> What's to stop someone from extracting and restoring the private key? Isn't the whole point of these chips that you can't extract the private key, so that if it gets wiped, it's definitely gone forever? > Sure, then how about addressing that issue rather than proposing to outlaw an entire mechanism entirely? We have a lot of things that can be misused, but (generally) only in extreme cases do we outlaw the tech itself. More usually, we have laws targeting the misuse of the tech. But this particular technology doesn't seem to have any legitimate uses.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Isn't the whole point of these chips that you can't extract the private key, so that if it gets wiped, it's definitely gone forever? I don't think these chips include TPM. But if that's the case, wouldn't you object to that on the same grounds that you object to efuses? > But this particular technology doesn't seem to have any legitimate uses. Myself and at least one other commenter has mentioned a few legitimate uses.
- josephcsible 3y ago> I don't think these chips include TPM. But if that's the case, wouldn't you object to that on the same grounds that you object to efuses? No, because it would let you generate a new key instead of remaining keyless forever.