3 ms·
The Tyranny of Structurelessness that Graydon recommends is well worth a read [0]. It's changed my mind on the question of the anonymity of the bad actors in th
by lolinder 3y ago
The Tyranny of Structurelessness that Graydon recommends is well worth a read [0]. It's changed my mind on the question of the anonymity of the bad actors in the repeated dramas in Rust.
What struck me as odd about JT's resignation was that they were nominally in the group that was in charge of everything. They were even primarily responsible for drafting the new organizational structure. Why, then, did they feel the need to resign when they had so much influence?
Having read Tyranny I think I understand. JT resigned because the recent episode revealed just how little influence they actually had and how little the supposed structure of the project mattered. What structure was there was a smokescreen for the actual informal power structures in the project.
Fasterthanli.me called out these informal networks and promised to stop participating in them in order to try to minimize their legitimacy [1], but I don't think that is going to be enough. The problem is the anonymity of the elite that is actually governing the project—we don't know who they are, so we don't know the informal structure through which decisions are actually made. Those who do know insist on keeping quiet, which does prevent an internet mob but also preserves those informal structures from scrutiny and dismantling. We need the people in the know to come clean not so that we can unleash an internet mob but to lay bare the actual power dynamics. Until that's done it won't matter how much the formal structure changes, the informal structure will continue to dominate.
EDIT: I missed several developments[2][3] over the past few days, so it looks like there may already be progress may be being made on this front. Thanks to Georgelemental for drawing my attention to them [4].
[0] https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm
[1] https://fasterthanli.me/articles/rust-the-wrong-people-are-resigning https://fasterthanli.me/articles/rust-the-wrong-people-are-r...
[2] https://blog.rust-lang.org/2023/05/29/RustConf.html https://blog.rust-lang.org/2023/05/29/RustConf.html
[3] https://hackmd.io/p3VG_bK9TXOvtgh1oA2yZQ https://hackmd.io/p3VG_bK9TXOvtgh1oA2yZQ
[4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36139642 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36139642
- yawaramin 3y agoThinking about it, it's so weird. I don't recall any other language community that operates with so much secrecy that their leadership team is anonymous. Are the Rust leadership team so vehemently hated and harrassed?
- NoraCodes 3y ago> that operates with so much secrecy that their leadership team is anonymous The Rust leadership team is not anonymous; you can read about them on the rust-lang.org website [1]. The much-discussed "leadership chat" was created to enable process-all-the-way RFC acceptance earlier this year [2] and has been updated twice since then [3][4]. There was also public-facing communication about this [5]. I believe GP is referring to JT (and others) choosing not to name the people who decided to downgrade JeanHeyd Meneide's talk from keynote status. Those people have since publicly named themselves in relation to the incident. 1: https://www.rust-lang.org/governance https://www.rust-lang.org/governance 2: https://github.com/rust-lang/team/commit/3700516795a293493e897072ad31d1d0c04196d9 https://github.com/rust-lang/team/commit/3700516795a293493e8... 3: https://github.com/rust-lang/team/commit/09717c6540c476639604570b0fe68767c183a106 https://github.com/rust-lang/team/commit/09717c6540c47663960... 4: https://github.com/rust-lang/team/commit/2cea9916903fffafbfae6c78882d0924ce3c3a8a https://github.com/rust-lang/team/commit/2cea9916903fffafbfa... 5: https://blog.rust-lang.org/inside-rust/2023/02/22/governance-reform-rfc.html https://blog.rust-lang.org/inside-rust/2023/02/22/governance...
- sanderjd 3y agoThey have? I saw and appreciated Josh Triplett's post, but still find it mysterious who the original group of people were who were not comfortable with the blog post / talk and reached out to people about it. I'm not at all sure it's any of my business to know who they are, and I'm not terribly interested. I'm just saying that I don't think that part has been publicized.
- NoraCodes 3y agoMy understanding is that it was Triplett and Gould, but I could be wrong.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- returningfory2 3y ago> we don't know who they are, so we don't know the informal structure through which decisions are actually made Yeah, I'm starting to think that for the Rust dramas specifically we need to start publicly naming and shaming those involved. In the tech industry we have internalized the (excellent) idea of "blameless postmortems". We don't blame individuals for things that went wrong - we examine systems and structures instead. This idea is embedded in many of the links above: there is a significant focus on the structural mechanics of what happened. However, I think the blameless postmortem approach breaks down when people aren't participating in good faith. In that case people need to be given some other incentive to behave well. I think for Rust, unfortunately, we need add a new incentive: if you use back-channels to get something stupid done, you will be publicly named and shamed and you will be put under pressure to resign. I think this should be implemented for the current drama: we should have an exact play-by-play, with names, of what happened.
- sanderjd 3y agoI'm ambivalent about the anonymity question in the case of these rust issues (I think there are lots of both pros and cons and I'm not sure where I think it nets out), but note: Blameless postmortems are not anonymous. They often include a link to whatever change broke whatever broke, with the author's and reviewers' names right there at the top. They usually also include a "X happened at Y time" listing with the names of the parties involved. The point is to infuse a culture with the certainty that the postmortem is laying no blame, despite naming names. It's pretty hard to maintain that culture even for purely technical issues, and I think just gets harder for interpersonal issues. But the transparency is definitely valuable.
- nativecoinc 3y agoPeople love to latch onto Structurelessness but it seems that I can’t stop hearing about “leadership in Rust” this, “governance in Rust” that, “working group on the subcommittee” this-and-that for the last few years.[1] So an insider realized that they have less power than they do. So what? This isn’t “structurelessness”; it’s just the formal structures having less power in reality, and also insider infighting. As if informal politicking doesn’t happen inside ostensibly formal governance. And Graydon has (according to himself) been out of this game for ten years. Then he was like, “Oh this sounds like this meme that I like” (which he came up with as more of a bystander than an insider, by the way). [1] See the previous submission [2]. How many levels of leaders of the leadership chat on the leadership working group steering committee is it on when it tries to explain the chain of events. [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36101501 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36101501 > Fasterthanli.me called out these informal networks and promised to stop participating in them in order to try to minimize their legitimacy Concretely, he > Up until recently, I was part of two private online discussion spaces where a bunch of Rust people hung out. So he’s resigning from two private chats/forums about Rust. Okay.