4 ms·
Some great observations by Graydon here. And also in some ways unsatisfying, because he seems on a roll on some idea, but then he doesn't know the solution, an
by neilv 3y ago
Some great observations by Graydon here. And also in some ways unsatisfying, because he seems on a roll on some idea, but then he doesn't know the solution, and the proposal of hiring experts prompts nervous questions.
Who is going to find those experts? How do you prevent empire-building and fiefdoms affecting which experts are hired? How will the new people be aligned?
> a lot of people over the years have left the project, and a lot of the leaving has been on fairly sour terms. A lot of people feel regret and resentment about ever participating.
This happens a lot with projects. Though some of the odd vibes from Rust leadership lately are more concerning than some of the idiosyncrasies that have caused me to write off some other projects in the past. Hopefully they straighten that out a lot, before more damage is done.
- nativecoinc 3y ago> And also in some ways unsatisfying, because he seems on a roll on some idea, but then he doesn't know the solution, and the proposal of hiring experts prompts nervous questions. It’s a typical "compiler nerd" (any nerd) response. You don’t know something so you think you can outsource it to someone who has the required skills. Which is fine in a limited sense. But if the problem is political then you might get other problems if you outsource it too much.
- neilv 3y agoI've put my own Rust adoption on hold for now. I think they'll ultimately be successful-enough, in one form or another (e.g., if a big tech co that invested big can't affect the solution well enough, they can always effectively fork). But there's already too much nonsense going on in the world, and there's more attractive things to be working on right now, than org dysfunction you can see coming from a mile away. (PSA side note to any individuals/teams in a "stressful" project/org. Stress isn't only unpleasant and difficult; it's physiologically damaging you, and you can't perceive much of the damage until it's too late. And the kinds of stress that come from org dysfunction beyond your power to fix are IMHO worse than the usual startup kinds of problems that you can potentially overcome with creativity and smart/hard work. Push back on bad stress, decide when to walk away, and next time try not to go there in the first place.)
- dralley 3y agoI feel this is a shortsighted reaction when most languages have had something like this happen, repeatedly even. C and C++ have had the exact same issues with utterly grinding down attempted contributors, public sniping between committee members, etc. I'm not trying to minimize this because it deeply needs to be addressed, but using one language or another is a relative decision, and between Rust and C++ I still think C++ is more dysfunctional, Go doesn't really attempt to be a "community" led project in the first place, Java drama ended up in the Supreme Court, etc.
- neilv 3y agoBut the energy we could spend on, say, ramping up and migrating to Rust, at the moment, could instead be put into ramping up in doing something with LLM. That's the example I personally have in mind, but other individuals and organizations can usually think of multiple options for investing their resources, what directions they could head towards, etc.
- vore 3y agoRust and LLMs are very different domains... If you are writing systems software the choice is between Rust and C, not Rust and ChatGPT. This comment gives me the impression of someone using Rust to follow a fad, not because it is something that is useful to them.
- neilv 3y agoI guess many might've read it that way, so I'll try to clarify. I can already do systems programming in C or C++. If I'm investing in Rust, to do systems programming in some ways better, then I want to restore confidence that it's not already becoming dysfunctional in leadership. Fads come and go, some fad-followers hop jobs every 12-18 months (and really don't have to care much whether a fad pans out, because they'll just hop on the next one), but I'm trying to think strategically and longer-term about what I invest in.
- jdlshore 3y ago> Who is going to find those experts? How do you prevent empire-building and fiefdoms affecting which experts are hired? How will the new people be aligned? You can hire an “Organizational Dynamics” consultant. Their job is to help create healthy organizational structures. This doesn’t answer the question of who and how to make that hiring decision, but a good OD consultant will nip empire-building behavior in the bud. The decision becomes “is this person qualified to help with our sort of organization,” rather than, “will this person support my agenda,” which is an easier decision to make. An OD consultant will also be able to recommend or provide conflict resolution strategies, training, and mediation services. Grayson mentioned that as a possible root cause, and that seems very probable, based on what I know of typical geek interpersonal failure modes.