3 ms·
The paper quoted in the post says: > I show that fi rms bid excessively for the pool of incumbent workers at the expense of trying out new talent. (...) This p
by bambax 15y ago
The paper quoted in the post says:
> I show that fi
rms bid excessively for the pool of incumbent workers at the expense of trying out new talent. (...) This problem is most severe where information about talent is initially very imprecise
This is nothing else than the Lemon effect at work.
(As it happens I wrote a post about it today: http://blog.medusis.com/are-you-a-lemon http://blog.medusis.com/are-you-a-lemon )
The Lemon effect (first discussed in a paper from 1970) appears in markets where buyers know much less about goods being sold than sellers.
When the probability of buying a bad product is high, buyers only offer to pay the lowest price. Sellers of bad products will sell at that price, but not sellers of good products. Therefore, after a short while, all good products are pushed out of the market and all that's left are duds (lemons).
That explains why employers are willing to pay more for incumbent workers: uncertainty about an incumbent workforce is much less than for "new talent", because the former is vetted by their current employers and new talent is, well... new.
- bradleyland 15y agoI think we're seeing a shift in this circumstance though. A central tenant of the Lemon effect is that it "appears in markets where buyers know much less about goods being sold than sellers". With regard to consumers, we have far more information available than ever before, and not in the most basic sense like spec sheets and feature lists. I'm referring to social intelligence, which provides far more subtle details. We are individually connected to more people than we have ever been in the past. As we, collectively, begin to share more and more of our experience in the open on the internet, the data set from which we can assess the satisfaction of a user base grows larger and larger. It has become trite to say that "big data" is where it's at for 2012, but I think we've all become a little bit numb to what that means. I would consider issues like the Lemon Effect to be "big problems". There's a very real possibility that we could solve this problem in the near future. That's pretty exciting.
- bryanlarsen 15y agoI think that the "overpaid CEO effect" talked about by Terviö via Cowen is similar to and related to the "lemon effect", but I'm not sure I'd go as far as to say that it is the lemon effect. If I were to oversummarize the two effects, I'd summarize the lemon effect as "an abundance of lemons depressing prices" and the overpaid CEO effect as "an abundance of lemons raising prices".
- ojilles 15y agoI think the latter summary should read: "if determining the 'lemon-ness' of a product has a high cost, it lowers the drive for finding more non-lemons and increases both the price and tenure of the existing ones" (Not sure if that makes sense in _your_ example, but thats how I read the paper)
- eru 15y agoThere's a somewhat similar effect in other segmented markets. (I hope segmented is the right word here.) In areas with rent control, the bits of the property market that are less restricted tend to be pricier, because they have to absorb all the excess demand.
- dasil003 15y agoYes, but there's a critical difference. New cars are the most expensive (ignoring restorations) with the most well-understood value, then they depreciate over time. With tech workers the opposite is true.
- mathattack 15y agoWith tech workers it's always tough to know, though, right? The average quality goes up, but so does the variation. What makes it tougher is the average non-technologist has a hard time quantifying technology people. "This one is good, but 2x good? 5x good? 10x good? 10x good for the task at hand? "