The given response very clearly and unambiguously does not answer the given question. I think most native English speakers - if they were reading/listening car

The given response very clearly and unambiguously does not answer the given question. I think most native English speakers - if they were reading/listening carefully - would interpret the mismatch of verb tense as an intentional attempt at not answering the question while simultaneously sounding as if it does. If someone gave me that answer to that question I would repeat the question to them with an emphasis on “did.”