2 ms·
I get this, but I worry that the metaphorical quality of hallucinate implies belief in consciousness. It may have surface qualities analogous to what we call ha
by ggm 3y ago
I get this, but I worry that the metaphorical quality of hallucinate implies belief in consciousness. It may have surface qualities analogous to what we call hallucination in conscious beings, but to backwards intuit because we decide this AI is "hallucinating" implies it's alive worries me.
In particular, that some theory of mind in a concept derived from AI contextual use of "hallucinate" could inform eg disease aeteology. I'd be delighted if our understanding of the mind and consciousness meant we had a theory which related to algorithmic hallucination but I don't believe that's true. We've taken surface effects and (I argue mis-) labelled them. There is no demonstrated link between AI hallucination and why it happens, and what happens in a mind. Why? Because we don't entirely understand what consciousness is. So, we have weak theories, based on experiment and observation. AI models aren't (as far as I know) informing this.
Hallucination (the AI term meaning) is an emergent effect in systems. And that doesn't imply anything about it, and how it relates to real hallucination in real minds.
Grokking is to humans understanding. Making intuitive connections, corollaries, inductive reasoning, abstraction, reapplication. It's strongly tied to cognition. I don't like this use of the term. While machine generated outputs display wildly inappropriate judgement between facts, and instantiate lies as syllogistic consequences it's way way off grokking as humans do.
So ask yourself: do you think pop Sci pundits and journalists and thus politicians understand this? Or do you think they hear "hallucinate" and think it's evidence of belief it's consciousness?