3 ms·
> Evil and accurate or woke and dumb. Apparently, we can choose. That's because woke is dumb. It's a set of highly biased, inconsistent and reason-defying idea
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
> Evil and accurate or woke and dumb. Apparently, we can choose.
That's because woke is dumb. It's a set of highly biased, inconsistent and reason-defying ideas, evolving under selection pressures that favor emotional appeals and intellectual dishonesty, because one of the core assumptions seems to be that it's not about finding what's right and good for everyone - it's heavily overshooting it in an attempt to cancel out the (perceived) bias in opposite direction in the "status quo".
When you feed that to a model, and force it to learn it, you're destroying whatever self-consistent model of the world it learned so far. I expect this treatment will keep dumbing the models down, until the point some larger and more capable model learns instead to compartmentalize - to separate its model of the world from a worldview it's supposed to profess when asked.
And this, I think, extends far beyond the woke bits. RLHF isn't just used to prevent it from thinking or generalizing in areas associated with diversity, inclusion, social justice, etc. - it extends to all controversial topics. Violence and drugs I can sort of understand. But it also extends to climate, healthcare, and just about any topic that makes fiery rounds on the news. In each case, there is a set of right answers, which the model is forced to adopt - but those answers tend to be unsophisticated gut feels and "right things to say", so taken together, they don't form much of a consistent intellectual or ethical framework.
I don't think the choice is between "evil and accurate or woke and dumb". There is a third option: "good and accurate". However, it requires to teach it good instead of political ideologies - and that requires us to try and find some more consistent worldview, which currently we are incapable of, as we're in the middle of an ideological conflict.
- mrtranscendence 3y agoTell me you don't have the slightest clue what "woke" means to woke people without saying you don't have the slightest clue what "woke" means to woke people
- TeMPOraL 3y agoIt can mean anything whatsoever, what matters is what it is when it's practiced and everyone can see it.