3 ms·
Hasn't this area of law been pretty much static for 100+ years? Surely this exact case has happened before? It's gotta be pretty common for a company to be
by londons_explore 3y ago
Hasn't this area of law been pretty much static for 100+ years?
Surely this exact case has happened before? It's gotta be pretty common for a company to be wildly profitable for a while, then suddenly bankrupt, and some owners have extracted all the profits in the meantime.
- ethbr0 3y agoI think the difference here is that it was a family company (providing a "singular" benefiting target to vilify and pursue) and the number of aggrieved parties. If it were instead 1,000 different shareholders and corporate officers, I think the public would have lost interest.
- dylan604 3y agoI think this is downplaying the effect of the devastation their actions have caused. Pretty much everyone knows someone impacted by their products. As the degrees of separation increases, so does the number of people brought into the world of addiction. personally, i know many people that have opiate addictions, and not one of them was introduced to them from buying them on the street or were addicts of anything prior.
- tomatocracy 3y agoNo idea if they're completely unique but the legal circumstances here appear to me to be at least unusual so this certainly isnt a common company bankruptcy story: shareholders agreed to pay money into the bankruptcy estate of the companies in return for a release of related, but separate, litigation claims from third parties against them.
- ethbr0 3y agoFrom my reading, trading money into a bankruptcy pot in exchange for personal liability protection didn't seem that unusual and is apparently commonplace nowadays. Whether it should be or not... probably not. But then we'd need much tougher laws to compel compliance with personal judgements as a consequence of bankruptcy proceedings (e.g. revoking citizenship, foreign country cooperation, etc). If we removed the possibility for liability protection as part of a deal, shareholders would have less incentive to cooperate financially, and so there'd need to be a bigger enforcement stick to balance the equation.
- tomatocracy 3y agoI guess there's a spectrum - at one end are consensual settlements, in the middle somewhere are non-consensual settlements of claims where party A is suing party B because party B did something to reduce the value of party A's claim in the bankruptcy estate, and at the most controversial end (like this case) are non-consensual settlements of cases where party A sues both the bankrupt company and party B over something they both did. The fact that this got overturned on initial appeal and then the original agreement reinstated on further appeal does suggest that it's at least legally controversial. The arguments made by the court seem reasonable enough (that this may be the best chance for those suing the Sacklers to get any money out of them given the jurisdiction and counterclaim issues, and that the litigation would likely be expensive and time-consuming if it were to proceed) but I suppose it will strike many as odd that a bankruptcy court gets to make that judgment (and without actually hearing the cases themselves).