3 ms·
Legal: probably. I don't expect consumers installing their legally bought software on a machine the manufacturer didn't approve to hold up in court. Without br
by jeroenhd 3y ago
Legal: probably. I don't expect consumers installing their legally bought software on a machine the manufacturer didn't approve to hold up in court.
Without breaking the EULA: no. For the same reason you're not allowed to install Windows on an ARM Chromebook.
Legally and without breaking the EULA: only the Darwin kernel and the various open source tools that can run on top of it.
If you've bought an OS install disk, I'm not sure how enforceable "you may only use this disk on hardware we sell" is in countries with consumer protection laws (i.e. large parts of Europe). In some jurisdictions, you would even be allowed to reverse engineer and patch any code that breaks compatibility.
If you're using a license tied to your MacBook on another machine, or pirate a copy, that's probably illegal in every way possible.
In theory you can install Lion, software you can physically buy and the last way to get a separate OSX license, install it, probably legally, and then upgrade the OS through official installers. That becomes a complex legal matter very quickly (as you often need to fake hardware IDs of real Apple devices to get through the process) as every upgrade comes with its own EULA, but it's a way forward.
However, blocking these installs is pointless anyway. We're at the point where docker run -it [...] sickcodes/docker-osx:ventura spawns a VM for you.
Lastly, as long as the software was developed on a Mac and tested with the open source kernel on other platforms, there's no legal reason why they couldn't have created an emulator. Darwin is a free kernel in almost every sense of the word and while their customers may be breaking the TOS between themselves and Apple, there's no restriction on selling software that may break the TOS if run on the wrong machine. With Macs being Intel PCs capable of running Linux and Windows, often lacking special drivers from Apple, targeting generic x64 seems like a perfectly fine solution.
- antonvs 3y agoThanks for the informative comment. > With Macs being Intel PCs capable of running Linux and Windows, often lacking special drivers from Apple, targeting generic x64 seems like a perfectly fine solution. Of course they're quickly becoming ARM64 PCs now.
- jeroenhd 3y agoThat's true, and I think it's going to be the end of the old Hackintoshes as well. At some point a version of OSX will be released that will only be available on aarch64. Until Microsoft sells Mac compatible Windows for ARM licences, the "you can use it in bootcamp" defense becomes a lot harder to argue.
- fragmede 3y ago> Legal: probably. I don't expect consumers installing their legally bought software on a machine the manufacturer didn't approve to hold up in court. Unfortunately, the Psystar saga says Apple can forbid running their software on unapproved hardware. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psystar_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psystar_Corporation
- jeroenhd 3y agoThere was much more going on with Psystar. For one, they were preinstalling OSX on these machines without the license to distribute the OS. That's never allowed. I don't think consumers acting on their own will be treated the same way, nor that VM developers that sell software that will run on legitimate Macs can be sued for possible abuse of the license on other platforms. Furthermore, Corellium's virtual machines were deemed legal despite everything else. Apple being Apple, if they had legal recourse for suing VMWare, they definitely would have, years ago.