4 ms·
You personally using an AI system, regardless of how brilliant it may be, is not going to suddenly turn you into a threat to society. Nor would a million of you
by somenameforme 3y ago
You personally using an AI system, regardless of how brilliant it may be, is not going to suddenly turn you into a threat to society. Nor would a million of you doing the same. The real threat comes not from the programs themselves, from things like a military deciding to link up nuclear weapons, or even "just" drones or missiles, to an LLM. Or a military being led on dangerous and destructive paths because of belief in flawed LLM advice.
The military makes no secret of their aggressive adoption of "AI." There's even a new division setup exclusively for such. [1] The chief of that division gave a telling interview [2]. He mentions being terrified of rival nations being able to use ChatGPT. Given this sort of comment, and the influence (let alone endless $$$) of the military and ever-opaque "national security" it seems extremely safe to state that OpenAI is a primary contractor for the military.
So what is "safety", if not keeping these things away from the military, as if that were possible? The military seems to define safety as, among other things, not having LLM systems that communicate in an overly human fashion. They're worried it could be used for disinformation, and they'd know best. OpenAI's motivations for "safety" seem to be some mixture of political correctness and making any claim, no matter how extreme, to try to get a moat built up ASAP. If ChatGPT follows the same path as DALL-E, then so too will their profits from it.
So as a regular user, all I can see coming from "safety" is some sort of a world where society at large gets utterly lobotomized AIs - and a bunch of laws to try to prevent anybody from changing that, for our "safety", while the full version is actively militarized by people who spend all their time thinking up great new ways to violently impose their will on others, and have a trillion dollar budget backing them.
--------
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Artificial_Intelligence_Center#Successor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Artificial_Intelligence_...
[2] - https://www.defenseone.com/technology/2023/05/pentagons-ai-chief-scared-death-chatgpt/385963/ https://www.defenseone.com/technology/2023/05/pentagons-ai-c...