6 ms·
Think of the 100s of millions or even billions of hours of unhappiness caused by whatever utter wanker designed the windows update system. All that misery wait
by mattmanser 15y ago
Think of the 100s of millions or even billions of hours of unhappiness caused by whatever utter wanker designed the windows update system. All that misery waiting to go home to your actual life but you can't because your laptop's displaying 'Do not turn off or unplug your computer'. No, just sit here and watch me. Or those times you accidentally opened Word or Photoshop or MySql Workbench (god that's slow) or whatever. You made a mistake? Well fuck you. I'm not listening to you, says your computer, I'm just going to ignore you for a little bit.
That's why.
And they're not enormously complicated, paint opens instantly and has the same UI. Word is little more than a glorified textbox. Programmatically all the features make those programs enormously complex, but the actual common use of the programs are simplicity itself.
- talmand 15y agoDon't like that feature of Windows Update? Turn off automatic updates and do it manually when you wish. Although I agree with the annoyance of accidentally opening something like Photoshop and having to wait to close it. But a good number of resources that is loading is third-party stuff that demands to be present immediately on startup as opposed to being loaded on demand. But whatever. Paint has the same UI as what? I hope you're not comparing it to Photoshop or any other professional level software. I believe the modern version of Word is a good bit more than a glorified textbox. But then you point out exactly why these programs load slowly in your last sentence. Maybe just start using less complex software?
- mattmanser 15y agoTheir interface is the same. Are you utterly blind? Stop looking at the UX as a programmer and imagining the complexity of the features. The actual screen is displaying exactly the same stuff. There's a big white box to draw in and bunch of buttons to press. You do not need to initalize all the 3rd party tools, you just have to find out which tiny little icon to add on a task bar or extra menu items to add, and why didn't you cache that when the extension was first detected? And how silly of me, of course all the corporations these days let you turn off the updates on their computers don't they? Stop telling your users that 'if they just..', do the opposite with UI than you do with your code, start programming for the best case scenario, not the worst case.
- JS_startup 15y agoI once wrote a clone of Microsoft Word for a company looking to move away from Office dependency - I think you're really understating the complexity of something like Word when you call it a glorified textbox or say it should load as quickly as MSPaint because they both use the ribbon UI.
- irahul 15y ago>I once wrote a clone of Microsoft Word for a company Out of curiosity, when was it? Wasn't openoffice.org an option?
- Hemospectrum 15y agoThe chief complaint I have with HN's lack of reply notifications is that interesting questions like this one will go unanswered forever.
- talmand 15y agoThe interface may be the same but I'm willing to bet under the hood they are quite different on a large scale. You seem unwilling to admit that. I don't understand what you are saying about third party tools. Could you clarify? Is that whole sentence talking about the same thing because I read it as having four different topics in there. If a corporation won't allow you to adjust update settings then that's an issue to take up with IT since they are preventing you from doing what you need, not the software itself. What if the default settings were exactly what you wanted and your IT department prevented it, is that also the fault of the software? I think your complaint is misdirected in this case. Ask ten different people to define best case scenario and I bet you'll get several different answers. Which one do you choose? You can't make everyone happy but I guess since you're not happy then your way is the best choice? What you complain about telling users "if they just..." is what I call choice. When I say an application won't do something I need then I WANT the answer to be "if you just do this..." so I can have that choice.
- freehunter 15y ago>Their interface is the same. Are you utterly blind? Stop looking at the UX as a programmer and imagining the complexity of the features. The actual screen is displaying exactly the same stuff. Seriously? I mean, my Dodge Neon has the same gas, brake, clutch and steering wheel that a Ferrari 599 has, why doesn't it 0-60 as fast? Stop comparing engine size and complexity, it has all the superficial elements of a sports car! God, you're such a mechanic.
- JBiserkov 15y ago> You made a mistake? Well fuck you. I'm not listening to you, says your computer, I'm just going to ignore you for a little bit. The programs from Office 2010 have a _x on the splash screen which lets you easily minimize/kill the program in question. It's really snappy, works like a charm.
- georgemcbay 15y agoHave you used a recent copy of Word (eg. Word 2010) or any of the other Office software? It all opens basically instantaneously on my system, and my system is like 4 years old now. They still show the splash boxes this guy is complaining about but the splash boxes are blink-and-you-miss-it fast and then the real app is there. Less than a second from click to load of the real app. The Adobe apps still do have more significant load times, more like 5-8ish seconds, but RAM is cheap, just load that app once and keep it open forever. Hibernate your system instead of shutting it down cold so that the apps don't have to reload from initial state when you next use them. This also makes Windows pop up very quickly (but even from cold boot modern Windows only takes like 15-ish seconds on my (again 4 year old) system), which isn't anything to complain about compared to any other desktop OS out there. All in all, I'm in the group of people very confused about this post. I'm historically someone who absolutely hated long load times, but it isn't something I've worried about for any app or OS I use in years now.
- keypusher 15y agoYou think they put that notification there to annoy you? No, it's because of possible data loss and/or system file corruption if you turn off the power while the system files are being patched. Splash screens exist because the program is loading. If you want the functionality of Paint, or Notepad, open those instead. If you want Photoshop, you open Photoshop, and it takes a while to load because it is gigantically complex. If you want it to load faster, buy a new computer.
- jiggy2011 15y agoSurely Windows updates are applied via some sort of transactional system that can be rolled back and re-attempted if the process fails for whatever reason? Having a power cut during a Windows update shouldn't result in a completely trashed system.
- pak 15y agoSurprisingly, NTFS does allow for transactions [1] and this feature is implemented since Vista, while as far as I know, HFS+ on Macs has no comparable feature. Therefore what you say may in fact be true. I'm curious if cutting the power on a Mac while it's moving files into place will break a software update, or if the whole package receipt mechanism prevents that from occurring. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transactional_NTFS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transactional_NTFS
- keypusher 15y agoI'm not sure even transactional NTFS would protect you in this case. From the wiki link: Transactional NTFS is implemented on top of the Kernel Transaction Manager (KTM), which is a Windows kernel component. Because this is implemented on top of the kernel itself, if you have brought down the kernel in order to update files within said kernel, you likely are not going to be able to leverage the transactional rollback. You might able to do a system restore, if you boot from CD, but breaking your kernel is not an easily recoverable situation. I suspect there are actually safegaurds in the update procedure which protect against this situation, but things can go wrong and it is really not something you want to have to rely on.