5 ms·
Note that this is the end goal of Jeff Bezos and his company Blue Origin, who was a Gerard O'Neill groupie when they were both at Princeton. AKA "move dirty i
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
Note that this is the end goal of Jeff Bezos and his company Blue Origin, who was a Gerard O'Neill groupie when they were both at Princeton. AKA "move dirty industry into space and make Earth a garden planet".
Bezos does not expect to live long enough to see it happen, but he claims to want to put the building blocks in place.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerard_K._O%27Neill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerard_K._O%27Neill
- cjbgkagh 3y agoI don’t understand how it’s even remotely feasible to move dirty industry into space? It’s hard enough to build industry on Earth. Where would the biproducts (dirt) go? Wouldn’t it be far easier to make factories cleaner on Earth? This sounds like someone who has now truly lost the plot.
- nickelcitymario 3y ago> Where would the biproducts (dirt) go? On the website, they suggest that these byproducts, i.e. waste, could effectively be dumped into space, where the solar winds would carry it out to the asteroid belt. I have no expertise to determine if this would ever be viable, but seems like they do at least answer this particular question of yours.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoI guess that could work, I did not think of that. Not sure if it greatly improves viability but venting into the solar winds I guess could be an option. At low earth orbit wouldn’t most material fall back down to Earth, it’s not like they’d be vending hydrogen. And a very high Earth orbit would incur even greater costs of getting material into space. It still seems bananas. Edit: I checked and solar wind starts at 60K km so there is no solar wind at LEO and 60K km is way beyond geostationary where it is already considered too expensive to bring things back to Earth.
- nickelcitymario 3y agoI had the same questions! But again, this is where my knowledge fails me. For example, if you release C02, how far away from earth would you need to be for it to not get caught in Earth's gravity? Still, it's a fascinating idea.
- wongarsu 3y agoAnything within Earth's sphere of influence [1] (about 90000 km) will initially be in orbit around Earth. Unless you give it a kick that puts the highest point of the orbit further away from earth than that. Unless you shoot stuff away with railguns, the relevant question might be "at which point are solar winds a bigger factor than drag". I guess it's highly dependent on the exact gas. We lose Helium that way from earth (buoyancy brings it up, where solar winds catch it), so at some height it should work for CO2. It only really works for gases though, and then only for things that stay reasonably gaseous in orbit (low pressure and large temperature swings). For any solid or liquid you have to worry about it crashing into you on one of the orbits, and at orbital speeds tiny things can impact with a lot of energy. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sphere_of_influence_(astrodynamics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sphere_of_influence_(astrodyna...
- cjbgkagh 3y agoThe more I look into it the less feasible it looks. My initial assumption is reflective of the peer comment that anything remotely heavy won’t have enough solar wind drag to get it out of Earths gravity well. Just to be in the solar wind alone you’d have to be outside the magnetosheath ~60K Km at its closest point, 35K Km is geostationary orbit which costs $10K kg to get to with falcon 9. And now you’d have to send up a whole falcon 9 in order to bring the non byproduct mass back to Earth which would defeat the purpose of venting CO2 to begin with. For those who don’t know it takes roughly the same delta V to bring things back down as it took to send them up.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoI don't know the answer to that. Though I'm wondering: If manufacturing were done on the moon, would it be safe and feasible to haul some wastes to the lunar equator during the cold of night and let it burn up when daytime temps naturally exceed the boiling point of water from solar power alone?
- pugworthy 3y agoI wonder what the impact would be on astronomy, whether space based or terrestrial?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pnut 3y agoI've come to the opposite conclusion, that taking heavy industry off planet is a godsend, because it allows capitalism's stagnating growth curve, fuelled by resource extraction with no regard to externalities, to plausibly continue indefinitely, with no environmental consequences - and the wealth poured back onto earth.
- mym1990 3y agoYou mean: “and the wealth poured back into Bezos pockets”.
- bequanna 3y agoWealth isn’t a zero sum game. New resources, new ideas, new efficiencies benefit all of us.
- ianburrell 3y agoHeavy industry will never move to space because it doesn't make sense economically. The main reason is that they are made in huge quantities that make it impossible to transport. Space elevators are pretty limited in quantity, think of them as a single rail line. Concrete is most made material and its components come from Earth. It is used on Earth. It is made in such quantities that it is produced locally because it infeasible to transport it long distances. Wood comes from Earth, used on Earth, and makes no sense to manufacture in space. Chemical industry is another good example, where a lot of the source materials come from Earth (nitrogen, petroleum, gas). All of the processes are designed to work in atmosphere and under gravity. My guess is that nitrogen-based chemicals will be shipped to space for a long time. Steel is made in huge quantities, with ore trains, ore ships, and giant steel factories. My guess is that even had a free iron asteroid in space, that wouldn't make sense to mine it because getting the results down would be too expensive. Also, there is a lot of large-scale manufacturing that wouldn't make sense to move because the result is used on Earth. Ship building is a prime example where building anywhere other than next to body of water doesn't make sense. Complex objects also have a lot of parts which means shipping them to space or moving the whole supply chain. The exception is industry being used for use in space.
- uoaei 3y agoHis entire series of enterprises has been about complete vertical integration. One part of why his favorite show ever is The Expanse.
- mym1990 3y agoJust curious, what does vertical integration have to do with The Expanse?
- uoaei 3y agoThe entire show is about political tensions that result from expanding corporate dominance and private ownership into industrial heavy mining operations like those out in the Belt, with all the attendant cost-cutting and consequent torture of the peons that that entails. Reminds heavily of stories heard from within Amazon warehouses. Amazon's push to dominate retail markets via Basics, etc., and the anti-competitive practices he enables, only serves to portend an obvious conclusion that Bezos wants to own not just the marketplace but every component of goods production.
- mym1990 3y agoGotcha. It is also one of my favorite shows(and I am far from a space theme enthusiast), but I think I focused more on the protovirus and what not, I should go back and re-watch it again!