3 ms·
Woodworking magazines are full of articles about tools and how they're used. The most interesting pieces are invariably about how the tool changes the user - ho
by jdietrich 15y ago
Woodworking magazines are full of articles about tools and how they're used. The most interesting pieces are invariably about how the tool changes the user - how Japanese saws change your mental approach to jobholding, or how routers tend to displace other tools and skills.
At a sufficiently high level, any discussion of craft inevitably becomes a matter of philosophy. The tools in a shop tell you about how a woodworker relates to wood; His attitudes shape his tool choices and his tools shape his attitudes.
- bergie 15y agoYep. I spent a weekend with a group of sculptors once, and they were debating the merits of particular drills just as eagerly as we discuss editors. Tools matter when you use them the whole day, every day. Though still it should be noted that most of programming is thinking, not typing ;-)
- dfc 15y agoI imagine that your sculpting friends would also note that most of sculpting is thinking, not physichally shaping a medium. Why do you think programming would be different?
- hsmyers 15y agoActually given the image you want to sculpt the rest of the work is 'knocking away the parts that don't belong'. This often takes most of the time in the overall process. There is also the matter of mounting the piece. This can take from zero (for free standing pieces) time to significant amount of time depending on the problem(s) involved. Overall I'd have to say that after 30+ years, doing the work takes more time than thinking up the idea. It's hard to be exact since it depends on hard to quantify things like how you come up with your ideas---many of mine were dreamed up while doing things like kiln watch (someone has to be around when you are burning the wax out of molds for casting bronze). Or when you are just sitting around with other sculptors and bullshitting. Something gets said that leads to an idea etc. Given the way the mind works, it would be hard to say that the thinking process starts 'NOW' and ends 'HERE' leading to time to pick up carving tool etc. Since I long ago came from the art department side of campus, I highly recommend taking some of these courses not just to get those non-major credits, but to give yourself other boxes to think in when you have to think outside the box. Must stop now, beginning to babble :)
- rfrey 15y agoThis analogy is exact. At the beginning levels people argue about power tools versus hand tools; shooting board vs. chopsaw, japanese plane vs. iron. Professionals have their tools that work, are interested in new tools insofar as they can improve results or productivity, but don't engage in recreational arguments. Masters of the craft have no dogma about tools and are always exploring, but also have strong opinions. They will rarely broach the topic but if someone is interested will talk for hours about their favourite tools. Their emphasis is on how the various tools change the process of work, not on how they change the work itself - the piece will be what they want it to be regardless of the tool. It's the worker-tool interface that's important at this level.