3 ms·
Remind me what companies Christiansen has run? He has been an academic/consultant his whole career.
by gaius 15y ago
Remind me what companies Christiansen has run? He has been an academic/consultant his whole career.
- marcusf 15y agoHm. I don't understand. Could you elaborate why that is important here?
- gaius 15y agoBecause there never was a "dilemma" to "solve".
- gtCameron 15y agoThe entire book is written as case studies of industries that this actually happened in. You could possibly argue that the problem doesn't apply to all industries, but its pretty hard to state that it flat out doesn't exist.
- _k 15y agoDr Christensen wrote in his book that you have to compete with your own products before someone else comes along and disrupts your market & profits. It's a no brainer but it's a difficult decision for most companies because most incentives aren't aligned with destroying revenue, making your products obsolete, ... Dr Christensen explains the dilemma and he offers solutions. Nothing's perfect but Steve Jobs may have solved the dilemma. Steve's decision was to basically kill the iPod with the iPhone and to kill the Mac with the iPad. You can still buy iPods and Macs so you could say nothing got killed, but you probably wouldn't be able to pull off decisions like that in big companies because they have well-embedded risk-averse corporate cultures. Note: I don't mean to imply it's all about the culture.
- rythie 15y agoHe literally wrote the book on disruption, which I expect, from your comment, you haven't read. http://www.amazon.com/Innovators-Dilemma-Revolutionary-Business-Essentials/dp/0060521996 http://www.amazon.com/Innovators-Dilemma-Revolutionary-Busin... He doesn't need to start a company to prove his point because it's not really about startups, it's about the problems big companies have. He wouldn't be the founder or employee number 1, he would be employee 10,000, the one they get when everything starts going wrong.
- gaius 15y agoI didn't say start, I said run. The dilemma he speaks of (yes I have read the book) sounds good on paper but doesn't play out in the real world, there are plenty of examples, is Coca Cola afraid of launching a new soft drink, or does Tricorn worry KFC is eroding the market of Taco Bell? Like most economics or sociology it's an elegant model that has little basis in reality.
- damoncali 15y agoGo read it again. I don't think you're grasping the idea of disruption as Christensen defines it. The examples you give are not disruptive products - they're just new products.
- destraynor 15y agoYou could have Googled this : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clayton_M._Christensen#Career http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clayton_M._Christensen#Career He founded Ceramics Process Systems Corporation, and served as chairman and president. He founded Innosight LLC He serves on the board of a number of others, and also works directly with a couple more. I'm all for calling bullshit on "big name, no experience" entrepreneurs, but Clay Christensen is simple not one of them. His work is phenomenal, there is so much to learn from it. Just because he's an academic, it doesn't follow that he's wrong.