2 ms·
There are a lot of intersecting rationales, but squatters' rights exist in most countries, including common-law ones like the US and UK, in part out of a desire
by _delirium 15y ago
There are a lot of intersecting rationales, but squatters' rights exist in most countries, including common-law ones like the US and UK, in part out of a desire to ensure that the legal situation of ownership doesn't diverge too far from the de facto situation of possession. Prevents the situation where someone digs up a dusty old deed from a basement showing they really own something that someone else is currently living on (and that maybe their parents were also living on); the on-the-ground facts of the past 100 years in that case trump the deed, regardless of whether it's genuine, promoting a sort of stability. Same with adverse possession and boundary disputes; if your neighbor puts up a fence and you don't challenge it, it eventually becomes the new property line, to avoid disputes always going back to ancient documents and upsetting the status quo.
There is, though, an intersecting economic-use rationale, which was especially prevalent in the American west, which is more like the copyright argument: something like, if you're not helping to make America great by neglecting your land, and someone else is willing to mine or farm there, well then move aside.