5 ms·
Comments are often worthless, and the reason comments are worthless is because there's no identity invested in them. When sites like HN and Reddit work (which i
by philwelch 15y ago
Comments are often worthless, and the reason comments are worthless is because there's no identity invested in them. When sites like HN and Reddit work (which isn't all the time), it's because there's a community of identities which are invested in the comments. When a site like HN or Reddit grows too much, though, most of those identities disappear.
Publishing your own blog post as a rebuttal, or emailing the author, are generally worth more, not only because of the identity involved but because there's a barrier of entry you won't bother crossing unless you're sure you have something to say.
- davewiner 15y agoI agree with this. A lot of it is people using your space to say random things that have little to do with the blog post they're responding to. At one point I realized that's just another form of spam. Why not post your screed in your own space? Because you have readers and I don't. Oh. Thanks soooo much. :-)