5 ms·
Sort of important and stupid at the same time. If you invent yourself around licence issues then you invite disagreement to licence terms and respect for the au
by ggm 3y ago
Sort of important and stupid at the same time. If you invent yourself around licence issues then you invite disagreement to licence terms and respect for the authority inherent in a licence drives you to this place.
But as an edge user it feels pretty "mummy and daddy are fighting" Stupid.
- givemeethekeys 3y agoPeople, at least the people that I know who use Debian as their preferred desktop OS care a lot about Debian's stance on licenses.
- bravetraveler 3y agoFedora is similarly firm [but slightly more amenable] about licensing -- I just wish they made a better effort of communicating it ie: the recent removal of patent encumbered codecs from Mesa People expecting Canonical-levels of disregard are bound to be disappointed
- NegativeK 3y agoI understood both Mozilla and Debian's stance during the Iceweasel era, and I thought they were both being pretty reasonable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- supermatt 3y ago> If you invent yourself around licence issues Mozilla is the party that lost out here - not debian. Mozilla basically reduced their brand presence for a decade for no benefit whatsoever. Debian still got the browser, but under a different name.
- warent 3y agoMaybe a trust issue? e.g. Mozilla did not want the Debian team the ability to create some strangely modified version of Firefox that would be mistakenly connected to Mozilla. Back then perhaps there was not enough context to know that Debian could be trusted. The interesting thing is that the pain actually did go both ways. The lack of Firefox and the need for Iceweasel actually confused me as a young developer, and put me off Linux for a long time, because it made it feel like a cheap knock-off. I was unaware that they were otherwise identical.
- zokier 3y ago> Back then perhaps there was not enough context to know that Debian could be trusted. You are implying that it is clear-cut that Debian is trustworthy here. In practice Debian did, and continues to do, heavy patching of packages to their needs, sometimes contrary to upstreams wishes. Iirc one of the issues here was the bug reports that Mozilla received that were in reality Debian-specific
- asveikau 3y ago2006 was around the time where they zero-initialized an entropy buffer in openssl to silence valgrind or similar tools. So the idea that debian would seriously botch a package was not so far fetched. That said, I used Debian, and didn't mind seeing iceweasel. It was kind of amusing, in fact.
- iforgotpassword 3y agoThat was pretty rad. Debian could generate up to 65536 different keypairs!!1
- ltbarcly3 3y agoDid Internet Explorer make you think Windows was junk or did you just download Firefox like everyone else? You can.. I mean people know this right.. You can download software on Linux and run it just like on Windows.
- mnw21cam 3y agoAgreed - it was very much a case of Debian taking the reasonable stance that it had standards that required it to only use free stuff, and wanting to have Firefox available to install, and then Mozilla requiring that they not call it Firefox, which they then quite willingly and correctly complied with.