6 ms·
Globalization is evolving, but does not seem to be reversing
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoIf it's more efficient, as long as market forces outweigh "localist" forces, globalisation will continue down the gradient¹ to some minimum "energy state". The amount of money involved means that to tip that balance, you need a very strong, coherent and stable localist sentiment. The complexity of the system and the willingness of individuals to attempt to wiggle though to the minimum means you need a very strong, durable and controlling government to keep the unstable system together in a way that persists for a very long time: at least many decades and beyond. This is tricky to do when countries that don't enforce localism probably will appear to advance more and faster, and especially tricky when you think that the very people who want localism the most also probably chafe the most at the idea of a more centrally-controlled economy. It's certainly more than possible that in the long, long run, the localist countries are the tortoises and the globalist ones the hares, but it's a hard sell to the public during that period when neighbours have ample food and electricity and infrastructure and you don't because you're still working on DIYing the supply chains. 1: this is a changing gradient: you might find that where the minimum is changes over time. For example what was once Germany² became Japan, then Taiwan and now China. This will continue, probably via South and SE Asia to Africa. 2: "Made in Germany" was originally an involuntary mark of an inferior imported product into the UK. Relevant in this context, because circa the 1880s, Germany had strong protectionist policies and thus had governmentally-forced local, low-quality and cheap (to other countries) industrial capacity. A century later and it's a mark of pride, so the tortoise is, if not in the lead, not doing too badly! That Germany was wrecked in the interim by two World Wars on the trot makes it hard to extrapolate that success onto other countries going forwards from the present.
- gishbunker 3y ago[dead]
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- bluetomcat 3y agoThe amount of international trade isn't a good indicator for measuring globalization trends. Two bordering countries could be trading raw materials to produce domestic products for domestic consumption. Globalization is when you are highly likely to be able to consume the same product at 2 distant points on Earth.
- photochemsyn 3y ago"The vast complexity of modern production" is not the driving factor behind globalization, as demonstrated by American manufacturing systems in the 1960s and 1970s. If you have the necessary raw materials, energy supply and labor force then manufacturing can go on anywhere - all you need is the know-how. The driving force behind globalization was the desire for cheap labor, the one component of the triangle that is most easily price-gamed. Of course, this doesn't affect trade between France and Germany, as moving a factory from one country to the other has no effect on production costs. In contrast, moving a factory from Detroit to Mexico, or to Indonesia, or to China? A 75% reduction in overall labor costs is all profit, minus shipping costs of course. Of course, it also drives down wages for those in the manufacturing sector while also shrinking that sector. The other side of globalization with respect to labor is the import of cheap labor when it comes to non-outsourceable jobs like construction and agriculture, which again drives down the average wage in these industries (as migrants tend to work for less) - and this even extends to the tech sector, with the H1B Visa program being a point of contention. This also drives a political backlash with consequences (see migrant field workers fleeing Florida en masse at present, for example, as the state passes laws banning their employment). Trying to write about globalization while ignoring the primary motivations and goals of the architects of globalization is kind of silly, and the main thesis - that modern manufacturing is just too complex to be done within the USA from start to finish - is just wrong.
- zokier 3y agoAlso more recently environmental regulations; afaik its not unusual to shift production to countries where environmental regulations, or their enforcement, is laxer to further cut costs. It helps that cheap labor tends to correlate with lax regulations.
- nologic01 3y agoIf globalization was a person it would be the ultimate Jekyll and Hyde personality There is what one might term the good, if not sublime, globalization. For as long as there are vast disparities in, e.g., life expectancy and educational level across the planet, our tribe lives a life out-of-balance (in the Koyaanisqatsi sense), unfair, unstable, miserly, antediluvian. Good globalization means flow of information, capital, people, goods that is (or should be) the great equilibrator, restoring balance. The other face of globalization is decidedly darker. It consists of what one might term conscious ESG arbitrage. Effectively pursuing short-term extractive profits by identifying global opportunities to hide environmental externalities such as pollution, exploit inferior labor conditions and benefit from poor governance systems (oligarchs and the like). Bad globalization means sharply raising inequalities within a region while modestly lowering inequalities between regions. If localization was a person it would be the ultimate Jekyll and Hyde personality There is what one might term the good, if not sublime, localization. For as long as one region lives at the expense of others, slurping (ultimately by force) resources and human talent from across the planet our tribe lives a life out-of-balance (in the Koyaanisqatsi sense). The good side of localization means that, by-and-large, communities in all regions become adapted to and live in equilibrium within their own ecosystems. The other face of localization is decidedly darker. It consists of what one might term Ideology arbitrage. Effectively pursue narrow-minded, isolationist policies and otherization, based on politics, religion or other discriminating factors in order to prop and persist a sub-optimal power structure arrangement. The bottom line on globalization/localization is that they are sufficiently ill-defined that every political agenda can find something useful. Yet as the above juxtaposition hopefully illustrates, it does not take that much to start being more honest, less obfuscating, about what we are really talking about.
- darth_avocado 3y agoWhat is interesting is that everyone who opposes globalization for what it does in terms of labor market conveniently forgets that localizing also comes with a lot of darker things. We want to manufacture iPhones on US soil entirely? Well, where are those factories going to be? What children will live in dangerous health conditions in perpetuity because of the pollution that will come with it? Where will all the waste go?
- whitemary 3y agoStupid article, but funny that the title gives a nod to Karl Marx's "history moves in a straight line" analysis. Liberals have been furiously criticizing this idea for 150 years.
- dang 3y agoCan you please not post shallow dismissals, please not call names, and please make your substantive points thoughtfully? A different version of your comment here could have explained your point neutrally and in detail—which I think could have been quite interesting and we could have learned something from. But this type of flamewar putdown just pours toxins into the environment. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=share%20know%20learn%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful. Note this one: "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something."
- motohagiography 3y agoMost of the predictions of the negative aspects of globalization from the 90s came true, specifically, about the hollowing out of working class jobs, the polarization that would result, and the erosion of western values to accomodate the despots we trade with. I was against globalization then because it was just a way for governments to collude with one another to dilute their accountability to their national constituents. Today, these governments literally import voters and distribute them throughout their country to prop up their political parties in contested areas because natural citizens don't vote for the looting and demolitions of their own societies. Globalization just became "globalism," and remains a cynically anti-democratic and anti-nation state movement that is the expression of a totalitarian urge. It is not reversing, but its growth has taken a brief break. Its architects know it is going to cause conflict, and judging by what we saw of them in the first few rounds, I suspect they are only resting and organizing for the next phase.
- jamilton 3y ago>the erosion of western values to accomodate the despots we trade with What do you mean by this? > Today, these governments literally import voters and distribute them throughout their country to prop up their political parties in contested areas because natural citizens don't vote for the looting and demolitions of their own societies What governments are you referring to?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cataphract 3y ago> What governments are you referring to? Even glossing over the latent xenophobia in the commentary, let's just think if this makes any sense. You need to specifically allow immigrants in that will gote for you, they'll have to wait 5 or more years to become naturalized citizen and at the end... naturalized citizens typically vote at much lower rates than the native born. Not a great plan. Much easier to suppress voters or kick out those that won't vote for you. See Jim Crow, or the expulsion of the Arab population of Israel before and after the 1948 war (without which Israel wouldn't even be viable as a Jewish state).
- sacnoradhq 3y agoThis is not news. Thomas Friedman expounded on this in writing about 2005. There is no going "backwards" to continuing to find cheaper sources of labor, new markets, and greater availability of everything everywhere all at once. This has the long-term net effect of flattening all wages and prices globally.
- incomingpain 3y agoGlobalization is a protected "thing" by the US military. The very design of the US military, especially the navy, has clearly indicated the US military will not be protecting this much longer. For China to continue shipping their junk to north america will take a huge increase in their naval power. OP's graphs show clear stagnation since ~2009. When Obama did his affordable care act, he found the USA was extremely dependent on Chinese pharma. He set the deglobalization trend going. Trump accelerated this into a trade war and Biden turned it into a cold war. Where we are at now is that globalism is done; but the logistics systems aren't sure what to do. Container shipping is super cheap but the insurance and fuel costs are sky high so they are struggling to be profitable.