3 ms·
Can we detect companies doing bad things, today? Yes, and we still have a hard time containing them and their externalities. AI will just mean more of the same
by actionfromafar 3y ago
Can we detect companies doing bad things, today? Yes, and we still have a hard time containing them and their externalities.
AI will just mean more of the same. It will make companies even more efficient at what they already do. It will be detected, it will be resisted, but will it help?
That's the big question IMHO.
- civilized 3y agoI find this to be a much more plausible area of concern than standard horror-story AI doomerism. But the more we shift our focus from fantasy to reality, the more we have to acknowledge reality, as Maciej does in this talk. It isn't plausible to prevent all the great powers from developing AI. We don't have that level of cooperation in the world today. We are going to need to adapt to this by keeping up with our adversaries, whether they be hostile nations, corporations, or mad scientists.
- DirkH 3y agoStandard rebuttal to this is if we banned human cloning we can ban AGI. Also China stands to gain from a ban on AGI. Anything that the CCP thinks it can't control it doesn't like. Also China gets the vast amount of its AI capabilities from the West because of tech's "move fast and break things" culture, which means security is not prioritized and tech leaks common. If the US bans AGI, the other powers don't have a choice. Their domestic capabilities are not up to the task without snooping on US research labs and AI tech startups. The biggest boon to foreign AGI research is the US. The argument to not regulate AGI used to be: "AGI is impossible or very far away, AGI can't ever be dangerous enough to worry about, AGI R&D cannot be stopped and is inevitable" Then it became "AGI can't ever be dangerous enough to worry about, AGI R&D cannot be stopped and is inevitable" Nowadays all I hear is simply: "AGI R&D cannot be stopped and is inevitable" Yes it can be stopped, same as human cloning. Coordinating to regulate its development isn't some magical unreachable goal.
- civilized 3y agoThe economic and strategic benefits of developing AGI are... not comparable to those for human cloning.
- actionfromafar 3y agoI’m not even talking about AGI. We can be in deep trouble long before that. And then where do you draw the line? Human cloning is a distinct and clear line. Ever more clever AI agents is not.
- DirkH 3y agoVery valid point and very valuable question. In this regard it is clearly different from human cloning and I should have thought of that. Obvious in hindsight. In my defense though, if we can find a distinct clear line for AGI, my point stands that we can coordinate and regulate it. But yea... Your point stands that by the time we draw the line it might be too late.
- Barrin92 3y ago>Yes, and we still have a hard times containing them Only because we're most of the time not properly motivated because there's no urgency. When a real threat, like a war or a virus say, comes around suddenly we can organize things pretty effectively. It resembles the Bill Clinton quote about controlling the internet being like nailing jell-O to a wall. Yet autocratic governments have done that, and not just that but turned it into quite scary systems of control, with little difficulty. Just like 90s cypherpunk fantasies about digital anarchy these AI scenarios are nerd revenge fantasies. The intelligent guy outsmarting the big guy, but in reality physical power always wins.
- actionfromafar 3y agoOnly… what? I don’t understand what you are arguing here. Climate change is already an existential threat to millions of people. Yet companies do what they do best - optimise for their paper clip production.
- Barrin92 3y agoclimate change is a risk to millions of people but it's not an existential risk. Just sadly a big one with the people worst affected having little say in anything. That kind of threat also for AI I think is worth worrying about. I fully expect autonomous weapons to be a concern, showing up in the worst and poorest warzones first probably. However this is different from the largely fantastical genuinely existential AI risk scenarios. The appropriate comparison here is nuclear weaponry and we literally have global controls with not a single company or even a rogue actor having ever used one.
- shkkmo 3y agoClimate change is not an existential risk to humanity, it may be an existential risk to modern human societies, it is definitely an existential risk to millions of people. > The appropriate comparison here is nuclear weapons Then complete the comparison. Nuclear weapons require specific materials and technology that can be controlled and the testing of any developed weaponry is fairly easy to detect. Despite these advantages, there are several countries that have them. If nuclear weapon proliferation is your comparison, then it sure looks like we will fail to prevent or stamp out the development of superintellegent AI. It we did succeed, what would it look like? We'd need to impose strict controls on computing capacity and it's usage. We'd need inspection regimes for every server farm, etc. It would require massive effort and fundemental changes to our society.