3 ms·
What is the reason for the wait times, though? If it's availability of doctors, I don't see how paying for private insurance magically makes doctors less busy
by kelnos 3y ago
What is the reason for the wait times, though? If it's availability of doctors, I don't see how paying for private insurance magically makes doctors less busy and able to see you. And if that does work, then it just means that the mostly-unavailable doctors are prioritizing people who can pay them more, which isn't exactly a great outcome either. Or am I missing something?
- otherme123 3y agoThis is how it happens in Spain: public doctors work from 8:00 to 15:00, with long queues. The same doctor has a private office from 16:00 to 20:00, where the queue is almost zero. There are some doctors that works exclusively public or private.
- lostlogin 3y ago> The same doctor has a private office from 16:00 to 20:00, where the queue is almost zero. If there is a queue, the price is too low. Surely a good business optimises price such that there is no queue and maximum revenue?
- brigandish 3y agoIt may be that the service provider (in this case, a doctor) realises that to price too many people out would be an optimisation that ignores that not all kinds of suffering are equal e.g. yes, optimise the pricing of Playstations and flight tickets and some people will miss out and feel bad, but the suffering of those priced out of a medical procedure is worse. On the other hand, if we allowed a freer market in medicine (anywhere, no particular target country in mind), seeing doctors make more money treating something should spur on new trainees, thus more doctors in that specialism, and hence price drops and improvements in waiting times and possibly techniques, but that would require that freer market that so many seem against.
- lostlogin 3y ago> that would require that freer market that so many seem against. I’m not sure that medicine could ever be a poster child for the free market. It’s tightly regulated for good reason. Is there anywhere that has free market medicine? I’d like to read about it, but wouldn’t want to use such a system.
- brigandish 3y agoYou think the kind of regulations that are being discussed in this thread are good things? They don’t seem to benefit anyone but insurance companies. Tell me, why shouldn’t you be able to walk into a doctor’s office and they be able to tell you how much a test costs? I wonder what regulation makes that impossible and what intended good it is supposed to make possible.
- lostlogin 3y ago> Tell me, why shouldn’t you be able to walk into a doctor’s office and they be able to tell you how much a test costs? I can. I live in New Zealand. Medical practice here is plenty regulated and complying with these regulations is a meaningful percentage of my day job. Not all of it is worthwhile, lots is.
- brigandish 3y agoI'm glad to hear that, even if it's not particularly relevant to this thread, but still worthwhile hearing about. It doesn't clear up why you think a free market and regulations are opposites.
- Klinky 3y agoA literal free market is one without regulation. If you want a regulated market, don't call it a free market.
- 3y ago