5 ms·
Inner workings revealed for “Predator,” Android malware that exploited 5 0-days
- olliej 3y agoActual analysis seems to be at https://blog.talosintelligence.com/mercenary-intellexa-predator/ https://blog.talosintelligence.com/mercenary-intellexa-preda...
- usr1106 3y agoEveryone who has reason to fear a state actor should not use smart phone except for truly innocent activity. It's just insecure. Probably some immutable Linux distro would be better. Are there guides out there how to do that for non-experts? Without being opposition in some of that state, most of us handle money in their insecure devices. Can we be sure that "ordinary" criminals don't have enough access for their purposes?
- dngray 3y ago> Everyone who has reason to fear a state actor should not use smart phone except for truly innocent activity. It's just insecure. The real lesson here is to not have unsupported devices in your possession. This malware uses 5 exploits which were from 2021. > Probably some immutable Linux distro would be better. Are there guides out there how to do that for non-experts? Android is an immutable system, but it doesn't help when people won't upgrade to a supported device. A "linux distribution" isn't going to help when there are proprietary firmware components that aren't updated. > Without being opposition in some of that state, most of us handle money in their insecure devices. Can we be sure that "ordinary" criminals don't have enough access for their purposes? Easiest way is to minimize having unsupported devices. The Pixels have a 5 Y support period that includes the underlying firmware. This article is misleading, they're not "zero days" when they were discovered 2 years ago.
- saagarjha 3y agoSupported devices, including Pixel phones, are often behind on security patches. Using such a device is better than using something completely supported, but that doesn't mean you'll be immune from these kinds of attacks. (Note that the exploits are from 2021 because that was when they were discovered–they are true zero days.)
- hypertele-Xii 3y agoThe real lesson is to mandate minimum support. Otherwise bigtech will use this as an excuse to destroy the environment for profit through increasing planned obsolescence.
- oezi 3y agoI would require 5 year mandatory security updates for all devices and another 5 years of support which customers can purchase for a fee which is capped at 5% of the sale price per year. Manufacturers which don't fix CVEs within 90 days must accept returns at full sale price. That would fix the whole economics around vulnerablities.
- jeroenhd 3y agoThe EU is working on a law that forbids selling devices with known vulnerabilities. This means manufacturers will either have to patch their stuff quickly or risk getting their entire lineup banned from sale if a serious security issue is found in their hardware. Stores will probably demand support lifetimes as well or they'll be stuck with unsellable stock once a company decides that three years of updates turned out to be too long after all. I think further provisions are necessary, such as source code escrow; once you go out of business or drop software support for a product, the entire code repository should open up to the public to fix it themselves, including the necessary keys to load the replacement software. It shouldn't matter if you use the same code base for other devices that you do support, if you're maintaining that code you may as well push those fixes out to older devices. The biggest issue with phones and tablets is that often the problem lies within kernel driver that the manufacturer has no control over. Qualcomm and friends are the biggest crooks here, sometimes dropping software support for their chips after only two or three years, with no realistic alternatives for sourcing SoCs.
- saagarjha 3y ago> Everyone who has reason to fear a state actor should not use smart phone except for truly innocent activity. It's just insecure. Of course, this is a terrible state to have to be in. > Probably some immutable Linux distro would be better. Nope > Without being opposition in some of that state, most of us handle money in their insecure devices. Can we be sure that "ordinary" criminals don't have enough access for their purposes? Generally "ordinary" criminals find it to be more cost-effective to phish you
- _kbh_ 3y ago> Without being opposition in some of that state, most of us handle money in their insecure devices. Can we be sure that "ordinary" criminals don't have enough access for their purposes? A Android or iOS full chain is likely worth a couple million American each. Due to the extreme prices you can be sure when governments use it they do their best to hide their tracks to not burn the vulnerabilities. Stealing someone’s money is probably a very noticeable way to burn your exploits or at least alert someone to fact that their device has been compromised.
- ufmace 3y agoYup this. These vulnerabilities are far too valuable to use for petty crime. You'll never get an equivalent return from using them to compromise a handful of phones, and if you use them on a large scale, they'll get noticed and patched fast. It's pretty much only used by Governments on whoever they consider to be an enemy of the state.
- hungryforcodes 3y agoSo you recommend we carry a laptop around in our pockets instead?
- TechBro8615 3y agoIf your threat model involves hiding your activity from a state actor, you need to worry about warrants as much as you do malware. From that perspective the entire operating system is working against you, since your adversary can simply subpoena Apple or Google for your cloud storage and access logs, which will reveal as much compromising data on you as even the best malware.
- miohtama 3y agoWith NSO, Cytrox, other companies, why do all commercial malware comes from Israel? Do Israelis hate freedom of press, journalists and human rights more than others?
- saagarjha 3y agoCytrox is Macedonian with a presence in Israel. NSO is entirely based out of Israel (although owned by some private equity firm outside of the country after they were sanctioned).
- ReptileMan 3y agoIt's Israeli and they just put the stamp made in Macedonia in Macedonia. for export reasons.
- mupuff1234 3y agoThe Macedonia part is purely a shell company.
- m5r 3y agoI don't understand why you're being downvoted, you're simply pointing out facts and raising a good question. I'm interested to find out why too.
- hunter-gatherer 3y agoThe comment above yours gives a real explanation, where OP posits a question whether Israelis "hate" freedom of expression. This isn't a good question or observation and is something I'd expect from a 9th grader. Of course israeli's don't hate freedom of expression. Who would answer "yes" to that? OP also suggests an answer with the question OP posits-an unsavory answer given the audience of HackerNews nonethless. OPs comment was not researched, obviously negatively biased, and doesn't even have a reasonable suggestive answer.
- localplume 3y agobecause they're extrapolating from a few spyware countries come from israel -> does every single israeli hate freedom of press, journalists and human rights. its a pretty bad faith argument and borderline racist anyway Israel isn't the only one selling spyware software. There are a metric ton of sellers, operators, and people just selling zero-days to any bidder the answer to their question is that Israel is a dense, highly educated country with a lot of expertise in computer security and other technology areas. VRED is a difficult and exciting area of work, and the pipeline from gaining these skills in the military and translating it to private industry is very real. it has nothing to do with freedom of the press, journalists, or human rights
- asah 3y agoyuck, clickbait title: the exploits were from 2021. CVE-2021-37973, CVE-2021-37976, CVE-2021-38000, CVE-2021-38003, CVE-2021-1048
- danparsonson 3y agoYou think no-one uses a phone more than two years old? Most manufacturers drop support for older models fairly quickly so I bet there are millions of unpatched Androids older than that in the wild.
- acidburnNSA 3y agoSeems like the clickbait is to call those zero-days rather than 'previously discovered issues that have been patched upstream'
- danparsonson 3y agoOh I see, well "exploited" put it in the past tense for me but I can see how that might not be totally clear.
- costco 3y agoYes, but the term is n-day (not 0-day) and is increasingly a problem especially in IOT devices: https://www.trendmicro.com/zh_hk/ciso/21/k/n-day-exploit-protection-strategies.html https://www.trendmicro.com/zh_hk/ciso/21/k/n-day-exploit-pro...