7 ms·
Private spies hired by FBI and corporations infiltrate Discord, Reddit, WhatsApp
- voidfunc 3y agoThis should surprise no one.
- programmarchy 3y agoSpies pretending to be gamers online is… a far cry from James Bond. Who are these people.
- predictabl3 3y agoEvery day it's a toss-up which I shout more frequently in my head, given the state of discourse about [any number of topics] in the US: (1) "life is not a [removed] movie" or (2) "get a hobby/friend; mind your own business". Today, it seems to be the former. Putting aside my reservations about power, authoritarianism and my trust of the US Government, I'd be pretty shocked and nearly appalled if they didn't do this. Between police forces and the military, authoritarian powers in the US give billions to private companies in the name of espionage and defense. I think there's a certain LOTR-namesaked company that is a known name around here. Why would the FBI be any different?
- underdown 3y agoThe 4th amendment should prevent them from spying on us without cause.
- RobotToaster 3y agoIt doesn't apply to private companies, which is probably why they outsource it.
- ok_dad 3y agoA piece of old paper with some words won’t do anything, we need to ensure the government listens to those words. Lately, I feel like there isn’t much we can do that’s not radical to get them to listen.
- refurb 3y agoThat's the reality of a lot of intelligence work. It's not spies doing dead drops, sneaking into homes to plant bugs. It's collecting and analyzing information.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoIt's playing online games and trolling for lulz in this brave new world.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoWhat are our governments spending money on? How is this possibly a profit-making private enterprise unless it's funded by government? It feels like outsourcing a pre-crime department. If this industry exists outside of normal law enforcement it needs unbelievably tight regulation. What powers do these private companies think they have? Do they pass information on to actual law enforcement, and if so, does actual law enforcement do any checks and balances on the information they're receiving? I don't know if this is next level paranoia or just another scary angle of the same level of paranoia post-911. I'd also like to be employed by the government to play games and chat online: FBI and CIA spies had created fake personas to hunt for potential terror plots discussed in online games, such as World of Warcraft and Second Life, as well as on platforms like Xbox Live. Those initiatives fizzled after the intelligence agencies found little to no evidence of terror communications. I'm interested in arguments that may justify this existing as private industry. Edited to add: I like how the single sentence quote from an FBI official needed to include not one, but two, [sic]s. And “detect threat actors when they are young or starting out at 14 or 15, that's when I start observing and documenting their malicious activities.” Talk about justifying the very activity the teenagers are engaging in, ie. fuck authority. I feel like I want to educate the teens to be smarter, in both their life choices and opsec. I certainly hope law enforcement doesn't treat these teenagers with the blunt object that law enforcement is stereotyped to only be equipped with.
- ok_dad 3y agoAs a parent, I’d be fucking PISSED THE FUCK OFF if the FBI had been investigating my kid for nothing like this. I would have an absolute fit. I would demand action from my senators and congress critters. I would sue so hard for civil rights violations against underage kids.
- marak830 3y agoI'm not sure why you were DV'ed, I agree. As an outside (non-US) your policing organisation's seem so damn over the top, whilst at the same time your security (the:personal ownership and carrying of weapons ccw or open) seems fucking batshit crazy. I have never been able to get the two into a mesh in my head as to why they work that way.
- AHOHA 3y agoI’m sure there are spies even in HN too, why do you think all governments of all political views are against encryptions and actively trying to have some sort of a backdoors in there, part of it to save the cost/time of these infiltrations.
- tgv 3y agoBrowsing HN, is that spying? Or just trying to find out what people are saying/doing in public? Framed another way, surveying the web could even be labeled "democratic".
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoMy question would be: is the value provided worth the cost to the taxpayer?
- shshhshh 3y agoI was working for big tech unicorn. After receiving multiple death threats. I ran away. You know who did it right? The same organization that radicalizes young men.
- AHOHA 3y agoPart of it is profiling, data gathering, and part of it if you happen to mention something that is not-supposed-to-be-mentioned, you will be targeted by private comms, job offers, etc. to collect further info. Edit: for example, US military is buying locations data from a Muslim prayer app (1). You can assume also same happens for other apps by other 3 letters agencies, like dating apps, social media (including HN), and others. No action needs to be taken, just data gathering for whenever it’s needed. (1) https://www.businessinsider.com/us-military-location-data-muslim-prayer-app-xmode-babel-street-2020-11 https://www.businessinsider.com/us-military-location-data-mu...
- rurban 3y agoLike those guys trying to discredit RSA encryption, whilst endorsing the new shiny EC curves (with potential backdoors).
- Cosmopolitican 3y agoFBI list since the late 1990’s here. Way ahead on the online counterintelligence. Directly experienced egregious abuse to the benefit of insiders, celebrities, security state, wealthy, etc
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoAs in: you're on an FBI watch list? Are you able to lead a (semi-)normal life? I might be joining you, with my little tirade above.
- explorer83 3y agoSometimes I ponder creating a story about how different groups trying to infiltrate groups actually become the group itself. Like undercovers trying to prove to the group they belong but are actually just trying to one-up other undercovers from other organizations. Idk if I'm explaining that well enough or not.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoYeah, so an employee of ZeroFox thinks an employee of DarkOwl may be able to be encouraged to say or do something that could justify the cost of ZeroFox's government contract this month. The communications from the ZeroFox schlub to the DarkOwl narc give the DarkOwl narc the idea that the ZeroFox schlub could be the trailhead to an increased 2024 budget. And so on. Cue Keystone Cops clip.
- praptak 3y agoThat was a mini plot in Bill the Galactic Hero. A group of revolutionaries recruits Bill. When they actually start a revolution, every single conspirator quietly leaves the crowd to join a hideout of the secret government agency they were working for.
- veridies 3y agoYou're describing The Man Who Was Thursday. Great novel!
- pmoriarty 3y agoYou might enjoy G. K. Chesterton's 1908 novel The Man Who Was Thursday.[1] Spoiler from the Wikipedia plot synopsis: "In his efforts to thwart the council, Syme eventually discovers that five of the other six members are also undercover detectives; each was employed just as mysteriously and assigned to defeat the Council. They soon find out they were fighting each other and not real anarchists..." In 1977, Philip K Dick took this up a notch in A Scanner Darkly[2], in which the drug-addled protagonist is unknowingly spying and informing on himself. [1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Was_Thursday https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Was_Thursday [2] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scanner_darkly https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scanner_darkly
- throwaway29303 3y agoWow.
- pseudo0 3y agoMuch of this article appears to be taking advertising copy as gospel truth. There is an awful lot of snake oil in the "threat intelligence" space. Keep in mind that it's easy (and unverifiable) for these companies to allude to super important secret squirrel government contracts when trying to convince Fortune 500 CSOs to pay for their overpriced "dark web" scrapers.
- pharmakom 3y agoIs there any evidence that discussions on the dark web is a precursor to attacks? Any documented cases at all? Seems like BS to me.
- Nextgrid 3y agoEvidence is pretty much never considered in "enterprise security" purchasing. The entire industry runs on snake oil, which the buyers knowingly buy because they themselves only need it to tick some checkbox on an audit form and rarely care about actual security.
- libraryatnight 3y agoPretty sure I've argued with a few here :P
- squarefoot 3y agoHardly surprising. Governments fear what they cannot control, therefore one should assume that every communication platform is being actively monitored and infiltrated, no matter what the laws say. The fight against encryption is their means of telling us that it's becoming too costly for them and we should stop getting in the way.
- gavaw 3y agoLiterally all we did all day in efnet was call every new, suspicious user a fed. (You can tell I'm old because we used the word "fed" instead of "glowie")
- throwing_away 3y agothat's exactly what a fed would say, glowie
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DiabloD3 3y ago"All the men are men, all the women are men, and all the children are FBI agents"
- drekipus 3y agoreminds me of a good twitter account "Tweets by feds" https://twitter.com/SuspectFed/status/1661695951269171202/photo/1 https://twitter.com/SuspectFed/status/1661695951269171202/ph...
- Freedom2 3y agoOne thing great about HN is that the moderation team makes it impossible for the discussion to be infiltrated!
- hnisaciaasset 3y agoNo need to infiltrate HN. The site is run by people under control of the CIA. How many Epstein people get their promotion here? How many co-invest with YC?
- hunglee2 3y agowe fell for the 'big tech bad' narrative promulgated by the media (likely also infiltrated by natsec...) who manufactured consent for big government 'reign in silicon valley' without realising what that implied. Worst case scenario of super popular big tech, now indirectly controlled by big govt - a surveillance state - is here. Good job we have checks and balances etc
- kentrado 3y agoWe can't trust CEOs or the goverment to guide big tech to work for the common good. In my experience, the workers (not management) are collectively the most ethical entity within a company. It is too bad we have decided that workers should not have a say in how the company is run.
- i2cmaster 3y agoThe only "big tech bad" law that really makes sense would be making non-free software illegal.
- hnisaciaasset 3y agoIt’s all controlled opposition. The NYT and a16z are on the same side. Just like Trump and Biden. The CIA has kompromat on all of them.
- jeffrallen 3y agoSnitches get stitches.
- Rebles 3y agoThis seems like a nothing hamburger article. FBI/Corporations agents posing as users in anonymous spaces is not exactly novel.
- ttctciyf 3y agoAfter raising the historical evidence for activity on these lines, the article seems to understate it a little. For example: > The veil was briefly lifted in 2011, when a set of threat intelligence firms plotted to disrupt the hacktivist network LulzSec and attempt to discredit journalist Glenn Greenwald. The contractors, led by the now defunct firm HBGary, devised a plan to infiltrate left-leaning organizations using fake online identities, in a bid to win lucrative deals defending corporations facing public scrutiny. This oddly makes no mention of the more sensational HBGary bid to discredit Julian Assange directly (see: [1]). A little further down it reminds us that the Snowden documents > revealed that FBI and CIA spies had created fake personas to hunt for potential terror plots discussed in online games but that > Those initiatives fizzled after the intelligence agencies found little to no evidence of terror communications. Odd that this should fail to mention the slides[2] accompanying a GCHQ talk concerning the activities of HSOC and JTrig ("Human Science Operations Cell" and "Joint Threat Research Intelligence Group") which show a mature program of "Online Covert Activity" (with accreditation!) was at least planned, with "Full roll out complete by early 2013, 150 JTRIG and Ops staff fully trained" in (inter alia) infiltration and disruption of online communities. 1: https://www.computerworld.com/article/2470522/bank-of-america-using-three-intelligence-firms-to-attack-wikileaks.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2470522/bank-of-americ... 2: https://theintercept.com/document/2014/02/24/art-deception-training-new-generation-online-covert-operations/ https://theintercept.com/document/2014/02/24/art-deception-t...
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- jruohonen 3y agoIf you watch the OSINT scene, this is hardly any news.
- nova22033 3y agoone official noted that the FBI team charged with monitoring groups due to assemble at the Capitol had just signed on with ZeroFox days earlier. So the only evidence he has is that the FBI signed up for ZeroFox in the days leading up to Jan 6th? The official said that the agency was still learning how to use the software Hmm.. The title makes it seem like FBI hired these companies to infiltrate these groups...instead of what actually happened: These companies sold FBI the data they already had.
- rvba 3y agoWhy cant the FBI just read all discord chatlogs directly via a door in discord? Or ist that just illegal to spy on own citizens without a cause, so they use contractors?
- paganel 3y ago> so they use contractors? Exactly, plausible deniability, I would say. Why risk your pension benefits or even a Congress testimony when you can say it wasn't you without technically lying?
- broupannoiffuto 3y agoThere is a lot of dodgy stuff in the field of threat intelligence. Many big companies client to some of those providers have access to information which clearly cannot be obtained through OSINT alone, or just surfing the dark web. I am talking which IP talked to which other IP, or even stuff seen from running botnets of infected machines in certain "interesting" parts of the world.
- ajross 3y agoExplain the dodgy bit here? These are all public/open forums. Open source intelligence work[1] is... routine and normal? What's the remedy you want to see? The government isn't allowed to read reddit or join discord forums? The government isn't allowed to hire people to read reddit or join discord forums? The headline is doing a lot of lifting with "spies" and "infiltrate", but as I read the article... quite frankly everything described is not only routine, and legal, it's literally protected by the first amendment. [1] It's a term of art. Obviously not the same thing as open source software.
- broupannoiffuto 3y agoAccessing netflow data "leaked" by ISPs as to who communicates with who ? Running botnets of infected machines in order to see what certain bad actors from APTs may be doing, where they could be trying to get hired, etc ?
- ajross 3y agoNone of that is alleged in the linked article...
- poopiokaka 3y agoIs that supposed to be a counter point to something? It’s relevant and related capability by orgs in the industry that the article mentions.
- surveilled 3y ago
- 666satanhimself 3y ago[dead]
- djaouen 3y agoGood, these communities deserve to be spied on lol
- _8j50 3y agoI'd say what this article talks about hardly scratches the surface. I won't say more but I am surprised at the reaction here, all of it is legal, if you don't like it, talk about passing laws. And what would you penalize? Lying on the internet? The 4th amendment is a restriction on the government not private companies. You have no right to expect people joining your discord server have honest intentions. Why are you using discord to begin with? You know, there is a reason gang members require newbies to commit a heinous crime when they join. How can I put it, trust establishment is not a technical problem, anyone can betray you, so find sociological methods to prevent that. But if you are a criminal, if you justify your harmful means by some ideological ends or use whataboutism to justify stealing from or harming others, the people that gain your trust and betray you are heroes to me! How can you act outraged when they too justify their means by their ends? Don't get mad at someone beating you at your own game. You all should know that an agent of these companies that engaged in hacking (getting past any security control without permission) is criminally (federal) liable. Conspiracy to committ most serious crimes itself is usually a crime. It's illegal to hack criminals. What is being talked about here is criminals that suck at vetting who joins their chatrooms. This is what krebsonsecurity does except these companies sell it as a service and they have certain useful commercial relationships. The FBI, if it was half as competent as people think it is (must be the suits?) would also legally be doing this if it paid people well. Undercover agents have always been a thing, they even get immunity for crimes while on the job! Unlike civilians doing threat intel. Lastly, this is threar intelligence research & development. There's a whole sub-field in infosec on what to do with intel once you have it. But really, marketing aside, this is HUMINT mostly. The information is technically about threats (humans) but it is usually not about their techniques. More like "look out for this IP" or "you're about to get ransomwares" or "this person's creds at your company is pwned". I hope I don't piss off anyone but if you really don't like this, make it commercially non-viable by requiring disclosure of compromised info or potential compromise to all affected parties. Oh, and just to add: I said I hope I don't piss off anyone because like they mention in the article, they monitor you at a young age and will develop enough text from you that you can never type long text like this without being identified (stylometry). But I don't think I've said anything that controversial. Just keep in mind, those of you who dabble in criminal stuff, even at a young age, you're never escaping that stuff. Before it was just stylometry, but I have no idea how much LLMs have improved this technology in recent years.