3 ms·
SARS case fatality rate was 14-15% (roughly). [https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/sars/estimates-sars-death-rates-revised-upward https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/sars/estima
by lazide 3y ago
SARS case fatality rate was 14-15% (roughly).
[https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/sars/estimates-sars-death-rates-revised-upward https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/sars/estimates-sars-death-rates-r...]
During the first year of the pandemic, figuring out much of anything except that bodies were piling up faster than they could be managed in all the cities was extremely difficult, and there was a lot of clear political manipulation of the numbers everywhere, so trust was... thin. To put it mildly.
COVID was clearly not as bad as SARS, but it was also clearly not the Flu.
So what was the correct policy exactly?
- Izkata 3y ago> So what was the correct policy exactly? Here's one easy one: Don't use medical jargon in news/media. For example, they shouldn't have called it a "novel coronavirus". It means something specific and totally different in a medical context as it does to the layperson, and I expect it was a huge part of the overreaction.
- lazide 3y agoNovel coronavirus isn’t medical jargon though? Or at least not very much? It was indeed novel, and it was indeed a coronavirus. They could have called it a ‘SARS novel variant 2019’ if they wanted to really stir up shit right? Unless the CDC gave everyone talking points they had to stick to (and somehow enforced it, aka China) it’s also not in the gov’ts power to tell the press how they should present things. There were a lot of mistakes, but that we can see them instead of being shot for noticing them is a pretty big plus - and definitely better than how a lot of places handled it!
- Izkata 3y ago"Novel coronavirus" in a medical context means "no one has immunity to this particular coronavirus". "Novel coronavirus" to the layperson means "this is a totally new virus and we don't know anything about how it's going to act", so all previous knowledge about coronaviruses was thrown out and relearned over the past three years.
- dent9876543 3y agoEven after all this time, I didn’t realise the distinction. I thought it was based in the “China created it” vs. “came from bats” arguments, i.e., man made (and this novel; of at least partial descent that our immune system had never before encountered), versus natural. Wow. Learn something new each day.
- dent9876543 3y ago> not in the gov’ts power to tell the press how they should present things. Is that really people’s understanding? Governments the world over made it their business to control what what put out — through the MSM, and many other channels. Many outlets were cautious of breaching the rules. In many cases, control was hands off — through peer pressure, if you will — but there were many well-publicised cases of direct intervention (for example, but it’s only one example, see the Twitter Files).
- lazide 3y agoFeel free to prefix 'In the US' to statements like that I make, since this forum is US centric. In other places, yes the gov't sends the press what they are allowed to say and if they deviate they'll be shot. No one (even the US) ignores the press entirely, especially when foreign actors are actively trying to manipulate the press. It's the degree of independent that matters though.
- projektfu 3y ago'The authors note that they included only patients who were hospitalized for SARS treatment. "If additional infections in the community do not lead to admission to hospital or death, the case fatality rate based on all infections would be lower," they state' In other words, they didn't have much of a handle on what subclinical SARS-coronavirus case fatality rate was. I'm not sure if hospitalized COVID-19 patients recovered better or worse than SARS.
- lazide 3y agoSARS was definitely much worse than COVID, and less infectious. It also wasn't infectious without symptoms. That helped it be contained, and it never escaped containment for very long like COVID did. It is very unlikely there were a lot of uncaught infections (unlike COVID) due to those factors. Not impossible a few slipped through though, which is why they put that in the paper. If it had, the death toll would have been astronomical. It was closer to Ebola than the Flu, and that had similar limiting effects in spread - it couldn't fly under the radar long enough, and it scared people enough that they took it seriously. With COVID, it could spread asymptomatically (and did), and it was never clearly fatal enough that EVERYONE took it seriously, which allowed it to spread easier. Another huge part of it IMO was it took awhile to develop reliable tests. The PCR test had up to 50% false negative rate for infections depending on when during the infection the samples were taken, and took awhile to get results back. Antibody tests didn't happen for a long time, so even retroactive knowledge was spotty, and antigen tests were a year+ out, and also had a relatively high false negative rate but at least were faster and more reliable (fewer false positives). Since it was clearly infectious without major symptoms, and the symptoms were often so vague (cold and flu like unless it got really bad) it was really hard to figure out what was actually going on.