But where are the countless, or at least fragmentary, stories where they did much, or any good? Secrecy and transparency and democracy just don't mix well, imo

But where are the countless, or at least fragmentary, stories where they did much, or any good? Secrecy and transparency and democracy just don't mix well, imo, if you want an absolute state that's fine. I can also agree that some rare situations may require absolute secrecy for some services, but that then must be limited and fully disclosed for later oversight, control and consequences.. 10 years is already a lot, 20 years absolute max, in my opinion. But almost nothing ever is, except what's leaked, that is shocking.